I think the context of these
I think the context of these economy ratings remains an important factor to consider. The C-Max was just released into winter driving conditions, wherein oxygenated fuel is the norm as is a higher degree of AC assisted defroster use. Throw in a slight hit for rain soaked highways as well, and I think it is fair to suggest that it's too soon to call this one yet. It looks like they lied, but more data is clearly needed.