I am the proud owner of a
I am the proud owner of a 2009 Jetta TDI. Yes, we all have different MPGs based upon driving style, season, etc. Using the EPA #'s makes it a fare comparison.
But what about warranty? Checking VW's website - both cars appear identical as to the 36 months/36,000 basic warranty, 144 months corrosion perforation warranty, 60 months/60,000 power-train warranty. I'm still looking for VW's battery system warranty.
Looking at the Toyota's official MSRP for a Prius battery replacement - it's $3,649 (less $1,350 "core credit") for a net $2,299 (before any taxes).
Even some of the earlier '04 VW Diesels have approached 200k in mileage before having any significant engine costs.
Time will tell.