Yes, it should be there…
Yes, it should be there. However, the problem was the discrepancy between the Carfax histories and other paperwork. I'd have been worried too if I caught it afterward like the OP did.
Odometer fraud is so common now and not always easy to catch. I think the OP used good judgement when she realized that what she read and what she saw in the vehicle did not match and encouraged her to look further before going after the car dealer.
Thanks for the input.