I Am Strongly Considering a Purchase of a 180,000-Mile Silverado, And The High Mileage, While Concerning, Isn't Deterring Me Yet

Work for Torque News, follow on Twitter, Youtube and Facebook.

I'm seriously tempted to buy a Chevy Silverado with nearly 200,000 miles, but there's one crucial thing holding me back, and I need your advice.

A 2008 Chevrolet Silverado with nearly 200,000 miles, would you buy it? That's the question I found myself reading tonight, scrolling through the Chevy Silverado groups on Facebook. At first glance, such a purchase seems questionable, but as I dove deeper into the discussion, something intriguing started to emerge: high-mileage Silverado's might be hiding surprising reliability behind those big odometer numbers.

John McLean, the prospective buyer who caught my attention, shared his situation candidly: “I’m strongly considering the purchase of a 2008 Silverado 4x4 with the 5.3L engine and 180,000 miles. The lifters and cam were recently replaced, and it’s still running on the original transmission. The truck appears to have been well maintained and cared for. To be honest, I was initially leaning toward a same-era Tundra, but I’ve recently heard good things about the second-generation Chevy trucks. For those who have owned this platform, does the high mileage concern you? What maintenance would you recommend after purchase? Thanks.”

Reading this, I immediately felt John's dilemma. On one hand, the Toyota Tundra is legendary for reliability and longevity; on the other, Chevy Silverados from this generation have their own solid reputation. It's not uncommon to find Silverados running strong well past the 200,000-mile mark, but it’s equally fair to wonder if buying a truck nearing two decades and almost 200,000 miles on its original transmission is playing with fire.

The Surprising Charm of a High-Mileage Silverado

There’s something uniquely appealing about picking up a high-mileage truck that’s been carefully maintained. Whether it's about budget, nostalgia, or the challenge of restoring something great, these trucks pull us in. And, to their credit, second-gen Silverados have a proven reputation for being workhorses, even as the odometer rolls past intimidating numbers.

But is mileage really the ultimate indicator of reliability, or should John, and the rest of us, look deeper into maintenance history instead?

Real Owners Chime In

Real experiences often offer the best insight. Travis Melton, another Silverado enthusiast, jumped into the discussion to share his reassuring story: “I have a 2014 Silverado 5.3 LTZ with 208,778 miles. It runs great, and I haven’t had any serious issues so far, knock on wood. It was very well maintained by the previous owner, and I bought it when it had 198,000 miles.”

Travis’s Silverado experience is comforting. If the previous owner has done their job maintaining the truck, mileage becomes far less of a concern. Still, maintenance history is key, and knowing exactly what's been replaced, or hasn't, can save significant headaches down the road.

Another owner, Jr Porter, offered an even more optimistic view, while also sharing some realistic cautions: “I have a friend who owns one with over 300,000 miles. Don’t get me wrong, it’s definitely seen better days, but aside from replacing the front hubs, he’s had minimal issues. These trucks are known to burn oil even when brand new from the factory.”

Jr Porter highlights a key consideration: oil consumption. The 5.3L engines, especially in these earlier Silverados, have a known history of burning oil. This doesn't necessarily indicate a serious issue, but it's something that future owners like John should absolutely be prepared to monitor closely.

My Personal Opinion on Buying a High-Mileage Silverado

Personally, I'm of the opinion that a high-mileage Silverado, especially from this era, can be a hidden gem if, and it's a big "if", the previous owner has cared for it meticulously. Trucks from this generation were built to handle hard work, and many have proven they can do so well past 250,000 miles. With recent replacements like lifters and cam, John's potential Silverado already has some significant updates, which is reassuring. However, I'd definitely keep a healthy emergency fund aside for potential big-ticket items like transmission or suspension components that might surface down the road.

What Maintenance Should You Do Immediately After Purchase?

If John decides to pull the trigger, there are several key maintenance items he should address immediately.

Transmission Checkup and Service

The Silverado's transmission is the most critical point of attention here. At 180,000 miles on the original transmission, John must pay close attention to any signs of slipping, harsh shifts, or unusual vibrations. It’s worth mentioning that even much lower-mileage Silverados sometimes reveal surprising transmission issues, like one owner found at just 7,000 miles due to faulty software, or another owner who discovered a strange cause of transmission surging at 138,000 miles. John should prioritize a thorough transmission fluid change, inspection, and possibly a flush if needed.

Oil Consumption and Engine Health

Given the history of these engines, John should immediately monitor oil consumption closely. Fresh oil changes at shorter intervals initially could help detect whether his truck is one of the notorious oil burners mentioned earlier. Frequent oil checks early on will be crucial.

Front-End Inspection

At nearly 200,000 miles, front-end parts such as ball joints, tie rods, and hubs could be nearing replacement time, just like Jr Porter’s friend's experience with replacing front hubs. Addressing these early helps ensure safe and reliable handling.

Cooling System Maintenance

It’s wise to thoroughly inspect the cooling system components, radiator, hoses, thermostat, and water pump, to avoid overheating that could cause expensive damage.

Electrical and Battery Check

Electrical gremlins can crop up on older vehicles, and even newer Silverados can face electrical nightmares, as documented vividly by one owner who faced issues after just 594 miles. For John’s 2008 Silverado, ensuring battery terminals, wiring harnesses, and fuses are clean and intact is a must.

Fuel Efficiency Monitoring

A decline in fuel efficiency is common in older trucks. While John’s potential Silverado predates the newer models discussed in an article about dramatic fuel mileage drops on a 2021 Silverado, it’s still important for him to closely monitor MPG. Any noticeable drop could signal issues needing immediate attention, from spark plugs to oxygen sensors.

Transmission Fluid Flush

Finally, at high mileage, performing a full transmission flush could extend the life of the original transmission significantly, though as one Silverado owner learned after spending $400 on a dealership flush at 45,000 miles, these procedures aren't always cheap. But they’re a worthwhile preventive measure for any high-mileage vehicle.

Moral of the Story for Truck Buyers

The most important lesson from John's scenario is simple yet powerful: mileage is just a number. The true reliability of a vehicle, especially something as robust as a Silverado, hinges on proper maintenance, careful previous ownership, and proactive care. High mileage isn't inherently bad; it simply demands careful attention, realistic expectations, and proactive investment in upkeep.

Have you purchased a high-mileage Silverado or another truck with similar mileage? Did the mileage ultimately matter to you, or was maintenance history more important? Share your experiences below!

Also, if you've bought a high-mileage truck, what specific maintenance items would you recommend tackling immediately after bringing it home? Let us know in the comments.

Narek Hareyan is a young automotive journalist with experience in a golf cart dealership and an interest in the automotive industry. Follow Narek on X for daily news coverage about cars.

Image sources: Chevy Pressroom and Grok.

Submitted by Joe (not verified) on March 29, 2025 - 7:24AM

Permalink

I owned a 2011 Chevy Silverado 1500 with 240,000 miles on the 5.3 liter engine and original transmission before I traded it off on a brand new 2024 Chevy Silverado 2500HD. I loved that truck and it was still running great, good and strong, with no real issues. It still had good power, didn’t knock or rattle on acceleration, and didn’t burn oil. The only thing I did, was that around 190,000 miles I noticed a lower oil pressure at idle. On the advice of my GM certified auto tech son, I started running 10W-30 oil in it, instead of the 5W-30 it calls for. That solved the low oil pressure at idle issue and the truck was still running great at 240,000 miles.

I have a 1997 GMC 5.7 vortec I rebuilt the engine at 3000 miles they are better quality engines to work on and they can go over 500,000 miles and I will buy another one if it's in good shape if it has 200,000 miles on it

Submitted by Ken (not verified) on March 29, 2025 - 8:30AM

Permalink

I bought my 2001 5.3 Tahoe from my brother for $2500 Always maintain everything on it has needed. It had 275,000 miles on it when bought. I rebuilt the transmission continue with all maintenance as needed. Gave it to my daughter (I found a 2003 with only 100,000 miles on it bought it) It is still running back-and-forth to California as well as other areas multiple times. it now has 375,000 miles on it and still running. just redid all ball joints tie rod ends those run for ever if taking care of properly.

Submitted by Oli j (not verified) on March 29, 2025 - 10:54AM

Permalink

I own a 2008 Duramax. I've had is 15 years and it's been the most reliable truck I've ever owned. It has 137,000 miles and runs perfectly. Never a breakdown, just a few maintenance items.

Submitted by Wayne (not verified) on March 29, 2025 - 10:41PM

Permalink

Well my input
I bought a 2003, Silverado 2500 HD 4x4 in 2004 new" from the dealer 100 miles , from test drives. By the way I still own it
6 litre 4 speed auto trans.the best truck I ever owned ( and still do) it is a extended cab 8 ft bed built for commercial use plowing and possibly sander, I have 86,000 miles on it may point? Great track is just changed tranmission fluid, twice and shifting is almost like new, the older silverado Lts are a great buy and more reliable than the new models

Submitted by Wayne Kidder (not verified) on March 29, 2025 - 11:22PM

Permalink

Check out the frame for rust, a major problem in the northern states. Despite serious winter maintenance by washing and flushing the undercarriage, My 2003 Tahoe LTZ was scrapped at 165,000 even though the engine, transmission, interior were very good. The trailing axle mount rusted out and broke. We found the whole frame was gone and was unrepairable. I he ad a similar problem with a 1996 Silverado where the frame rusted through right behind the cab. I didn't see any comments by the author that even hints at this (PS: I am an
automotive engineer with a Masters in Mechanical Engineering and hold patents on vehicle component design). Recommendation to manufactures?: use better (known) rust prevention technology. When you spend over $50K for a vehicle, an extra couple of hundred bucks is not an issue. WB Kidder

This right here! Experience with several low mileage gm trucks of this era, including an '08 with 50k.miles, has shown me 1st hand that frame rot is a horrendous issue on these trucks in Northern states. The "fully boxed" frame beneath the cab is really just a sheet metal tube welded up of MANY pieces. There are laps everywhere to invite salty water to creep in by capillary action. There are also holes all over the place for fixture pins. These allow the water and dirt to enter the tube where it rots from the inside. Much like looking for termites in a house, you want to take an icepick and probe the frame . Often it will go right thru. I've seen trucks that look like show cars on the body with 12-16" long sections of perforation in the frame.
I wouldn't hesitate at a 200k mile chevy from TX but ANY '08 from the snowbelt states is highly suspect.

Those era chevrolet pickups are the best. Ai have a 2000 chevy 3500 with 268,000 miles and it still runs strong. Used it for heavy hauling. Even the A/C still blows cold.. I would buy the 2008 Even if you had to rebuild the engine at some point, it would be cheaper than dealing with these brand new trucks with all kinds of issues...

Submitted by Dan Bergstrom (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 3:17AM

Permalink

Ij just bought a 2024 Silerado 1/2 ton to replace my 2005 3/4 ton. Funny thing is that I can't part with that 2005 with 197,000 miles on it. Bought it new in 2005. It is not only the best truck I have ever had, but it is the best vehicle, i have ever had period. My 2005 has the 6.0 and it's an HD. I have had no granny issues at all. It came with the large external tranny cooler on it. My 2004 express cvan came with a 6.0 but with no external cooler. The tranny on that went out at 80,000 miles. It burned up bad. I had the 2005 Silerado tranny pan dropped and a new tranny filter installed at 130K. I read about new trucks having tranny issues with low miles. I can't part with my 2005 because they don't make them like they used to. I wouldn't hesitate to buy an older truck that might need some TLC and some maintenance. My son-in-law has a 2004 with over 200K on it. The tranny was rebuilt by the original owner over 6 years ago and it is still going strong. Its cheaper to buy an older one and put a little money into it than it is to buy new and still end up with a tranny problem.

Submitted by JohnW (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 10:04AM

Permalink

I drive a 2010/4.8L-Reg cab/2wd, the absolute basic model with 115,000 miles on it... no issues. Highway MPG new was 18 when new. I finished a 400 mile run yesterday on the interstate driving between 75-80 (passing a few times a little higher) with the air conditioner running and got 17. Chevy was concerned with the transmission. If you hit the trip odometer setting past the trip it gives you transmission running temperature. Anything over 225 indicates real issues. Mine runs between 145 - 165.

Submitted by Vitório (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 10:49AM

Permalink

Had a 2000 Silverado 1500 LS regular cab. 300K trouble free miles before it was stolen. 5.3, 2WD. Miss that truck.

Submitted by Kevin Lestarjette (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 12:17PM

Permalink

I own a 2008 4x4 Chevy Silverado 2500 . I have over 250,000 miles and she still pulls Ike day 1. I love my truck. I'm pretty sure she will outlast me..
Regular maintenance is key

Submitted by Denny Dawes (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 12:43PM

Permalink

After my sons 100,000 mile high school GMC pickup ran him through college and beyond - to over 250,000 miles, My retirement plan was to buy low milage GMC/Chevy pickups. I ended up with 4, two 1500s and a Tahoe with 5.3s and a 2500 with with a 6.0. All purchased for less than $15K (add that up) and all with less than 80K miles.

My wife uses hers to pull a vintage camp trailer all over the NW and has put on around 40K miles. I do the same with mine and even made a trip to the Arctic Ocean with it and a beefed up vintage trailer. The others get some local running but have not eclipsed 80K miles yet after 4 years.

We take good care of them with tyranny flushes and oil changes. Have added a starter and alternator to mine ( mostly out of concern traveling in remote areas)

The thing that nice. We live 30 miles from a dealer so our local repair guys can handle most of the minor things without waiting in line and several trips to the dealer.
I think we're set for 10-20 years of running...after that they may take my drivers license away anyway

Submitted by Tom (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 4:15PM

Permalink

I have a 2013 1500 with 230,000 mi on it and I have a 2011 2500 with 255,000 mi on it only done transmissions and just of late engines are strong

Submitted by Steve (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 5:52PM

Permalink

I just sold my 2014 Silverado with the 5.3 and 6L80 transmission. It was 5000 miles short of 300,000 miles. It was a great truck overall. The only things I did to the engine were to replace the high pressure fuel pump under the intake and replace the thermostat. At 100,000 I had a tuner reprogram it. The estimate from ho tuners was 425hp. It was immediately noticable. I won't lie it was quick. Not many trucks could touch it, with the exception of the viper powered dodge I ran up on. He laughed at me.
The major issue I had was the 6L80. It went out at 130,000 I had it remanufactured. It went again at 230k and the third was quick at 250k I went to a friend who builds transmissions every day. I told him to treat it like it was his. I never asked what he did differently besides the torque converter. It was strong when I sold it. I never changed a thing under the hood for performance parts. I was stayed on top of the oil changed. Yes I used the onboard monitor. I stuck with 0w20 synthetic by mobile 1 with wix filters. Btw I still got 22 mpg.
Jaded by the transmission issues I bought a 2024 RAM with the 5.7 and 8 speed. Even with 300k I'll bet the Silverado will still smoke it.

Submitted by Andrew (not verified) on March 30, 2025 - 8:43PM

Permalink

Hell to the no I would stay away from 2008 and 2009 Silverados as they are on consumer reports worst of the worst list due to having way to many electrical issues

Submitted by Wesley Long (not verified) on March 31, 2025 - 10:30AM

Permalink

I have a 2000 GMC Sierra 1500 SLT 5.3 bought from my father. Proper maintenance all of its life and other than the small issue s like cracked window wiper fluid lines, it has 2,56,857 miles and runs strong. Just got inspection yesterday (good for another year) I hope.

Submitted by Tom Good. (not verified) on April 1, 2025 - 6:01AM

Permalink

I own a 2008 2500hd with 150k
No issue I could not fix in the drive. Transfer case, transmission,rear axles and front differential are great shape and serviceable for the next 100k. No lift kit just level kit.
my intentions are to fix and replace parts until I die. Or someone takes me out.
Get it before it's gone.

Submitted by LAURA CUPIT (not verified) on April 1, 2025 - 7:39AM

Permalink

If it helps I've got an '05 Silverado 4x4 with a 4.8 and it about to roll over 307000 miles runs like a top motor transmission and rear end.. I haven't had to do anything major to motor.. I have a pan gasket slow leak other than that no motor issues .. And none with transmission or rear end.. The front end suspension has given me the most issues although I call that regular maintenance due to the type of work that I do... I've definitely gotten my money's with out of this truck.. Good luck. If it were me I'd probably go for it...

I have a 2019 Silverado with 150,000 miles.
By FAR the worst vehicle I have ever owned.
I've spent more on maintenance and repairs than the payments.
I wouldn't take one if someone gave it to me.

Submitted by Al Wilson (not verified) on April 2, 2025 - 7:31PM

Permalink

My 2005 GMC with 5.3 has nearly 170,000 miles. High oil consumption early on. My mechanic recommended synthetic and oil consumption stopped. Mechanic had other customers with same results. Been through three rear U joints. Front break assemblies with ABS and bearings replaced twice on each side. Misc electrical. PRNDL light burned out. Switch that turns light on when you enter no longer works. Very good truck. No major issues. I have changed tranny fluid twice. Oil every 5,000. I’d buy another 5.3 in a heartbeat.

Submitted by Dan (not verified) on April 3, 2025 - 8:12AM

Permalink

I am at 245,000 on my 5.3L 2012. The whole top end of the engine was redone at 177,000 when the AFM system broke a lifter, and the original transmission failed at 201,000. The CD player also died of old age and I haven't swapped in the replacement yet. All that said, with a good mechanic and the willingness to replace things as you go, you can keep one on the road much easier than one of the new ones.

Submitted by Doug Sakowitz (not verified) on April 3, 2025 - 10:32AM

Permalink

I read this article from beginning to end - I just had to add my 2 cents worth into the conversation.
I bought my 2009 Silverado (4x4, 5.3, a/c) from our local dealer here in Richmond, VA. (Now Hendrick Chevrolet)
It now has 155k on the odometer and runs as well as the day I picked it up.
I did, AFTER 9 YEARS, have to replace the original battery AND alternator. (Almost $1,100) Seems something shorted out in one of them, causing n g both to need replacement.
I did have ALL fluids changed (Amsoil) and plugs replaced when it went over 100k.
I would gladly leave here in Virginia and drive to the West Coast today without concern. The heat n air conditioning has always worked great even in our hot, muggy summers.
IF I WERE TO SELL MY TRUCK TODAY (which I would not) the person getting it would be buying a very reliable, good looking and comfortable truck.
This 5.3 has NEVER needed oil added between changes - always still on full mark.
What a great truck.
Doug Sakowitz

Submitted by RICHARD W MORIO (not verified) on April 3, 2025 - 6:45PM

Permalink

I purchased a 2014 silverado 5.3 litre 4x4 in April of 2024 with 141,000 miles . I currently have 167, 721 miles . I change my oil every 3to 4 thous. Miles using synthetic 0 - 20 weight oil and so far so good no tapping or knocking at all . No leaks either . Now when I bought this vehicle I felt noticed the trans shuttering , so I drove up onto the highway and sure enough the shuttering was horrific . So into the trans shop for a rebuilt . Since then I installed a AFM disabler which has me happy with both engine and trans driveability . So far no issues ? Remember I drive to and from work 130 miles a day . Hope this helps someone . PS Yes I'm a Chevy guy .

Submitted by Charles Wallace (not verified) on April 4, 2025 - 12:56PM

Permalink

My 2005,5.3 silverado still does a good job, major problem is it will nickel and dime you for ever, I call it the hungry beast. 170k miles.

Submitted by Gene Mullaney (not verified) on April 5, 2025 - 1:35PM

Permalink

I have driven Chevys all my life.
They easily go 250-300,000 miles.
No burning oil, no failed transmissions.
Service properly engine oil & tans fluid.
When the transmission get to be high milage DO NOT FLUSH, only regular fluid & filter change.
At 190,000 l had to replace the throttle body & belt tensioner and alternator.
My recent 5.3 needed a rear main seal at that 198,000 mark. Still, it doesn't burn oil. So at most l put 12-1400 into it in repairs. RMS is the only repair l had done by a garage. I also put american rotors & brake pads on it.
Lasty, it appears l need Lower bj's now at 208,000 miles.
Run's like a top! 16 city. 25-28 highway on clean roads.