I’m Choosing Between The Rivian R1S and The Tesla Model Y Thinking This May Be The Ultimate Adventure SUV for My Growing Family
This evening, while strolling through the “RIVIAN Electric Vehicles Discussion” group on Facebook, I came across a post by Kevin Brady. Kevin is considering the Rivian R1S to replace his 2018 Tesla Model 3. He currently owns a Model Y, but space is becoming a challenge with three growing kids and a love for camping and skiing. He shared his thoughts, saying:
“We love road trips, skiing, and camping, but the Model Y is getting tight. We use a cargo box and a hitch carrier, and it still feels like we’re maxing out space. I need a detailed comparison of the R1S trim levels and options to make the best decision for my family.”
Kevin’s dilemma is one that many EV enthusiasts face when upgrading to a larger vehicle. The Tesla Model Y is a fantastic electric SUV that offers efficiency, technology, and access to Tesla's Supercharger network. However, the Rivian R1S presents itself as a rugged, adventure-ready SUV with ample space and off-road capability. Let’s dive into a detailed comparison to help Kevin and others in his situation make an informed decision.
Rivian R1S vs. Tesla Model Y: Key Differences
Storage and Space
One of the biggest concerns for Kevin is cargo space. The Model Y has 76 cubic feet of total cargo space, while the Rivian R1S boasts 104 cubic feet. Additionally, the R1S features a sizable frunk, under-floor storage, and a tailgate that makes loading and unloading gear easier.
Nicholas, a member of the Facebook group, shared his experience:
“I’ve never had a Tesla, but I’ve owned and currently have a Gen 1 Rivian R1S after having an iX. In terms of storage and capability, the Rivian is superior. With all the storage space and a roof box, there’s no issue fitting 4-5 people along with their gear, skis, etc.”
For a family that frequently travels with extra equipment, the R1S offers a clear advantage. Here’s why a Rivian R1S owner loves the storage and comfort on long trips.
Trim Levels and Battery Options
The Tesla Model Y comes in two primary configurations: Long Range AWD and Performance, offering 310-330 miles of range. The Rivian R1S, on the other hand, has multiple battery pack options:
- Standard Pack (270 miles range)
- Large Pack (352 miles range)
- Max Pack (400+ miles range)
Nicholas pointed out a key difference:
“Yes, the Gen 2 frunk is slightly smaller than my launch edition, but you can opt for a bigger battery. I’ve road-tripped to ski country and had no issues with range, especially with some planning, but since you’re already an experienced EV family, I can’t imagine it being a problem. One key difference: the Rivian isn’t as efficient as Tesla or most other EVs, so you’ll use more energy regardless. But I love it.”
While the Model Y is more energy-efficient, the R1S compensates with larger battery packs and higher off-road capabilities. A Rivian R1S owner tested range and charging capabilities over a 1,300-mile trip.
Adventure and Off-Road Capability
If off-road adventures are part of your lifestyle, the R1S is the clear winner. It comes with:
- Quad-Motor AWD (available in the Gen 1 model)
- Adaptive air suspension with 14.9 inches of ground clearance
- Drive modes for snow, sand, and mud
Kevin’s love for skiing makes this an important factor. The Model Y has AWD but lacks the same off-road versatility. Another R1S owner shares why the vehicle’s smooth ride and adventure readiness made it their top choice.
Charging and Road Trips
Tesla’s Supercharger network is unmatched, making the Model Y a better option for frequent long-distance travelers. However, recent developments allow Rivian owners to access Tesla Superchargers, mitigating this advantage.
For instance, one Rivian owner took a 1,300-mile road trip using Tesla chargers, which proves the infrastructure is improving for non-Tesla EVs. Read more about this experience here.
My Opinion
As someone who follows EV developments closely, I think Kevin’s choice ultimately depends on his family’s lifestyle. If efficiency, lower cost, and a more refined software experience are the top priorities, the Model Y is still an outstanding choice. However, if he truly values adventure, cargo space, and rugged capability, the R1S is the better fit. Personally, I find the R1S far more exciting, it’s built for adventure, can handle rough terrain, and still provides ample luxury. While it might not be as energy efficient as the Model Y, the trade-offs in space and capability make it a vehicle that can grow with a family over the years. Plus, the thrill of knowing you can tackle any terrain is an underrated factor that makes driving more enjoyable.
Final Thoughts: Which SUV Is Right for Kevin?
For efficiency, ease of charging, and compact size, the Tesla Model Y remains a great all-around EV. However, given Kevin’s needs for more space, better cargo management, and adventure capabilities, the Rivian R1S emerges as the ultimate family SUV.
Kevin’s dilemma is common among growing families who need to balance efficiency, storage, and adventure-readiness. The choice comes down to whether the superior range and efficiency of the Model Y outweigh the R1S’s extra space, ruggedness, and towing capabilities. If you’re considering the R1S, check out insights on the latest Gen 2 features.
Moral Lesson
Choosing the right vehicle isn’t just about range and price. It’s about lifestyle. A car should enhance your adventures, not limit them. Think long-term about how your needs will evolve.
Your Turn
What factors influenced your decision between a Tesla and a Rivian? If you own an R1S or Model Y, how has it worked for your family and road trips?
Please share your thoughts in the comments below.
Narek Hareyan is a young automotive journalist with experience in a golf cart dealership and an interest in the automotive industry. Follow Narek on X for daily news coverage about cars.