Skip to main content

I Traded a 2018 GMC For My 2024 GMC Sierra And Despite All This Bashing Against GMC Trucks I've Had Zero Trouble With My Truck

Are the complaints about GMC Sierra’s lifters and transmissions overblown, or are 2020-2023 trucks really the ones to avoid? Hear from real owners as they share the truth behind the controversy—and tips to keep your truck running strong.

Yesterday, while scrolling through the lively discussions in the 2019–2025 Chevy Silverado & GMC Sierra Owners Facebook group, I stumbled upon a post that stood out like a beacon of calm in a sea of controversy. The thread, started by group member Doc R., raised a thought-provoking point about the GMC Sierra and the ongoing chatter about lifter and transmission issues in GM trucks. In a world where online forums are often flooded with complaints, Doc’s perspective was refreshingly different.

Doc wrote: “I traded a 2018 GMC Sierra for my 2024 GMC. Consider all this bashing against GMC trucks with 5.3 concerning lifters and transmission. One question: what is the percentage of failures compared to the number of cars produced? Or maybe this is a question for CBS 60 Minutes! Under consumer fraud. I have had ZERO trouble with my new 2024 GMC Sierra.”

This sparked a flurry of responses, both supportive and critical, with group members sharing their experiences and perspectives on GMC Sierra trucks and GM as a whole. It’s no secret that every truck brand has its share of fans and detractors, but Doc’s comment—and the conversation that followed—paints a picture that’s more balanced than the doom-and-gloom often found online.

The Case for the 2024 GMC Sierra

Many group members echoed Doc’s positive experience with the 2024 GMC Sierra, highlighting that issues discussed online often overshadow the fact that the majority of owners enjoy trouble-free ownership. One commenter, JJ Merimonti, pointed out an important detail about the 2024 Sierra:

“The 2024 GMC Sierras have a 10-speed. There is no class action lawsuit for those. Just drive it and maintain it and don’t worry about it. Buy used extended warranty. Every manufacturer and damn near every engine today has issues. Blame the EPA and our elected officials.”

JJ’s advice to "just drive it and maintain it" is a sentiment that many truck owners can relate to. With modern engines and emissions standards becoming more complex, maintenance is crucial, and extended warranties can provide peace of mind for those concerned about long-term reliability.

A Veteran Truck Owner Speaks

Doc later elaborated on his history with GMC trucks, which added weight to his perspective. He shared:

“Since 1993, every 5 years, I’ve owned a 1500 Sierra SLT Premium Plus. Issues I’ve had: 93 had intake manifold, 98, 03, 08, 13—nothing, just standard maintenance. 2018 media center and oil coolant lines. Sounds like a GMC poster boy. Also 2013 and 2018 Acadia Denali with ZERO problems. Just oil, tires, and battery.”

It’s hard to argue with a track record like Doc’s. After decades of loyalty to the GMC Sierra, his confidence in the brand appears unshaken, even amidst ongoing debates about reliability.

A Mixed Bag of Experiences

Not everyone in the group shared Doc’s unwavering confidence, though. Some members highlighted concerns about newer models, particularly trucks produced during the pandemic. Michael Woods cautioned:

“All the shortages they’ve had over the past couple of years. I wouldn’t trust a truck—any make or brand—from 2020 to 2024, and these are the trucks I see people have the most problems with. All kinds of them breaking down with less than 30,000 miles. Maybe I’m mistaken, but seems like 2018–2019 was the last solid year Chevy had.”

This raises a valid point about the challenges automakers faced during the pandemic, from supply chain disruptions to parts shortages, which may have impacted overall quality.

Positives Still Outweigh the Negatives

Despite these concerns, other group members stepped in to defend the Sierra and Silverado, emphasizing that most owners don’t encounter the issues so often debated online. Ryan Breault made an insightful observation:

“Trucks from all the major brands have their issues. Most of the posts you see online will be about complaints and issues because people are looking to solve them. Often the ones who don’t have any issues or modify their vehicle won’t be posting.”

Another commenter, Ronnie LiPuma, added his voice to the mix:

“I’ve had zero issues with my 2021 Silverado Trail Boss I bought new in 2021, now 57K, and I absolutely love my truck.”

These comments bring up an important point: online forums are often disproportionately filled with negative experiences because satisfied customers rarely feel compelled to share their stories.

As Doc R. and others share their experiences with the reliability of the GMC Sierra lineup, and if you're curious about how this top-tier model stacks up, it's worth taking a closer look at how the 2023 GMC Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate Duramax delivers on its promise of luxury and performance.

Maintenance Tips for GMC and Silverado Owners

For those looking to get the most out of their GMC or Chevy truck, the advice from seasoned owners like Doc and JJ is invaluable:

  1. Stay on Top of Maintenance: Regular oil changes, tire rotations, and keeping up with recommended service intervals can prevent many common issues.
  2. Consider an Extended Warranty: If you’re worried about long-term reliability, an extended warranty can provide added peace of mind.
  3. Drive Without Worry, But Be Prepared: While modern trucks are built to last, unforeseen issues can arise. Keeping a contingency fund or warranty in place can save headaches down the road.
  4. Stay Informed, but Take Online Complaints with a Grain of Salt: Remember that forums often represent the vocal minority of truck owners who’ve had problems, not the majority who are happy with their purchase.

The Takeaway: Love It or Leave It?

The ongoing debate about GMC and Chevy trucks shows just how passionate owners are about their vehicles. Whether you’re a diehard GMC fan like Doc or a cautious buyer wary of pandemic-era models, it’s clear that every owner’s experience is unique. As Doc himself pointed out, the number of satisfied owners far outweighs the complaints—but that doesn’t mean legitimate issues should be ignored.

If the reliability debate around traditional GMC Sierras has you wondering about the future of trucks, you might want to explore how GMC is electrifying its reputation. The fully-loaded Sierra EV Denali Edition 1 is already here, and it’s redefining what a high-end pickup can be.

Now, over to you: Have you owned a GMC Sierra or Chevy Silverado? What has your experience been like? Are the concerns about lifters, transmissions, and pandemic-era quality justified, or do they overshadow the trucks’ many positives? Share your stories and thoughts in the comments below—we’d love to hear from you!

 

Armen Hareyan is the founder and the Editor in Chief of Torque News. He founded TorqueNews.com in 2010, which since then has been publishing expert news and analysis about the automotive industry. He can be reached at Torque News TwitterFacebookLinkedin, and Youtube. He has more than a decade of expertise in the automotive industry with a special interest in Tesla and electric vehicles.

Comments

Hank Warren (not verified)    December 7, 2024 - 6:50PM

I have had a 72,76,95,98, 07,11,12,15.
Silverado the 07 was a GMC.I never realy had any major problems with any .I love my GM TRUCKS AND CARS .

Roy (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 7:39PM

In reply to by Hank Warren (not verified)

I have had Chevy Suburbans for 20 years.

The only major issue I ever had was the main computer went done in one of them.

It turned that my washing the engine compartment at the car wash was the reason for the computer to pack it in.

Will buy another one in 25.

Mr. Miller (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 5:36AM

You have gotten blessed with it, plain and simple, I would have gladly traded my 23 for your 18 instead I see a Tundra in the works they are better all the way around, GM has turned their back on the idea of why trucks are made and paid themselves with over priced Cut down trucks with nothing but a Raspberry pi and a cheap touch screen! Pure junk, tell ya what get a nail in the tire and take it in they won't fix the nail hole but they will sell you another tire. Biggest SCAM on the planet.

Mark (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 7:04AM

I haven't owned a gm truck for many years. I did at one time own a 1978 c10 and years later a 1989 3/4 ton suburban. My experience with them was that they were definitely not built to last. The 78 was a rust bucket as most of them were, I got it third hand- original owner-my dad-then me. It was so far gone bodywise by 1987, not even a decade old, it was borderline unsafe to drive. The suburban was not much better in that regard. I was the second owner, and it too was starting to rot away by 1997. Mechanically, they ran well, but they were less complex then. I drive Ford trucks now, and believe me, I'm not here to say that they're perfect, but I have had a much better ownership experience with them than I had with the gm trucks. I drive a 2011 F150, and at almost 14 years old, it has held up so much better in both appearance and function than the trucks I described.

Brian Saxby (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 3:27PM

In reply to by Mark (not verified)

I've owned an 85 Chevy K10 over 10 years, before that it was y father's bought new, still looking new as when my father got it just regular maintenance and upkeep I'll own this truck till I can't drive anymore then I'll pass it down

Mitch (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 8:35AM

Traded my16 Silverado with afm system. Hated the transition from 8-4 and back again.other wise no prob.37 k. Now own 21 sierra. Love this truck.45 k. Dfm operates smoother,but I also installed dfm inhibitor. Only issue,brakes needed replacing at 40 k.$1500. will see how long new set lasts.

Remylabo (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 8:56AM

I've had a 96, 03, and 05 Silverado and then a 21 Sierra. None of them gave me problems until the Sierra!!! Not a single bad transmission or lifter noise or tap or miss fire until that FREAKING 2021 Sierra!!! Piece of EPA JUNK!! However it is a big sexy piece of junk

Woody (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 9:36AM

I bought my 2021 gmc elevation 4wd brand new. At 15k miles it started running bad and smoking I thought I had gotten bad gas/water from a gas station out of town. So I took it to dealership and ended up being my left side lifters completely shattered so they replaced that I'm under warranty of course then at 20k miles it starts stuttering like I'm running over a bunch of little bumps in the road took it to dealership they did some sort of computer/software update I forget the right terminology that used but it did nothing brought it back and they changed my torque converter and all has been well so far I have 30kmiles now.

Rick (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 4:37PM

In reply to by Woody (not verified)

I, have a 2021 GMC SIERRA SLT and the talk is True about the Lifters and Transmission. At 31,000 miles my Transmission started acting funny and now at 50,000 miles my #4 and #7 lifters have messed up. As of today my truck has been in the shop at the dealership since the middle of October because after they fixed the lifers, now they can't get the check engine light to stay off. They clear the code and test drive my truck and the check engine light is back on before they leave the parking lot. GMC HAS TO DO BETTER.

John McClure (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 12:20PM

I've owned a 1999 Siverado with the 5.3 vortec and now a 2017 Silverado 1500 High Country with 6.2. I drove the 99 from New to over 250k miles. Transmission and transfer case issues but none with the engine itself. Tha 2017 had lifter stick issue so installed dod/afm delete kit for less than the cost of replacing one lifter, one push rod and a cam. Neglible loss in mpg. Epa has driven many issues but gm has been responsible of others. Wish I could buy a GMC 2500 with a Cummins diesel. That's the only "hybrid" i have interest in. At the price, every maker should be ashamed of their trucks these days.

Tim Titshaw (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 1:34PM

In reply to by John McClure (not verified)

Sadly, my 2018 GMC Sierra started having Transmission issues around 10000 miles it has 40000 on it now but I have to baby it I'm afraid it's going to leave me I have had multiple surgeries so walking far at all is not an option really wish they would fix the problem I'm retired and in no position to buy another one I'm kinda stuck I guess GMC won't help me I have tried multiple times it's a shame

Murray Dubois (not verified)    December 10, 2024 - 3:54AM

In reply to by Tim Titshaw (not verified)

I have a 2022 RST Silverado and at 31,000 miles the engine failed and was replaced. At about 38,000 the pulley disconnected from the engine stranding me again and had to be towed.At 42,000 miles the vehicle shut off and was towed again and I was told that the engine needed to be replaced due to a broken crankshaft which destroyed 2 pistons which damaged the cylinders that they were in.I payed cash with part of my retirement and I have a pacemaker and hip replacement and can't walk far and had plans of buying a trailer and touring the country but that has changed due to the beautiful Junk GM has created.I am now looking for an attorney to sue GM for the mental anxiety & anguish they have caused me,ruining my retirement dreams and effecting my health mentality and physically.I have researched and there has been several issues with the 6.2L engines that GM builds.

Richard J Bergeron (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 1:59PM

I have a 2020 gmc,sierra 5.3,4x4 crew cab 10 speed tranny . I love this truck. I pull a 26" trailer up mountain roads all over brittish Columbia . I have under 20,000 kms as i dont drive it much unless on road trips . I have no complaints as of yet and it runs like a clock .

Jeff Warren (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 2:57PM

My 2019 5.3 Litre loaded Sierra has run flawless. 82k plus miles. Thinking about a new 2024. Bought at Becker GMC in Spokane with a power train for life warranty.

Charles Beall (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 4:10PM

Buying every 5 years? I guess they do "love their trucks!"😁 If my 2010 Tundra with 88,000 miles(nothing but
maintenance since new) serves me nearly as well as our 2004,Pilot with 376,000 miles(original engine,trans and radiator) I'll be happy.

Juan Martinez (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 5:29PM

I have a 2018 sierra denali 6.6 litter engine with 126000 miles. I Tow a 2019 north point fith wheel that weight 16,000 pounds empty and mesure 42 feet long. I have taken it to Florida,South Carolina,Alabama and many other parts of the country, best truck that I have ever owned, and I have perform the maintenance my self have no complaints. Love my truck.

Me (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 8:19PM

All I've owned were Chevrolet trucks, from an 88, 93, k1500s, 93, & 98, 10 suburbans, 08, 09, 14, 18 ,- 1500s, 98 - 2500, 01- 3500, and my current 22 HD 2500....
My 98's had head gasket issues, one cost me a target motor at 90k,
My 22 blew my mind, blown motor at 75k, due to lifter failure... serviced by the dealer every 5k, religiously... I'm beyond upset, as I love the truck .
Im lucky that GM is going 1/2 on a rebuilt motor that comes with 5 year 100k .
After reading the issues, all steming from the EPA bullshit 8-4 cylinder fiasco
GM isn't the only with the issue from what I've read... it pisses me off that for the money we spend on these vehicles, you'd think they'd last 300k miles not 80k

Angelo Bivi (not verified)    December 8, 2024 - 9:04PM

I've owned a 2015 Silverado LT from new. Have over 150k on it. Only issue I've had is the roof antenna seal leaked water into my headliner. Changed all my brakes at 100k. Heard bad things about afm so been driving in M5 (6 speed tranny). Just changed the transmission fluid, antifreeze and transfer case oil. Mechanic said everything looked good and keep driving in M5. Happy owner of 9+ years.

Dave Miller (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 4:13AM

In reply to by Angelo Bivi (not verified)

Owned GMs from 1974 both new and used until 1996, engines always used a little oil, always liked gas a lot no matter the CI, drove them hard and used them where the last one a 89 was a mess engine issues, rust, electrical headaches so moved to Ford. 96 F250 was really no better but felt more comfortable to drive, traded that for a 99SD 250 diesel, 340,000 miles, 24 years later later I recornered and rocker paneled the cab replaced the doors and painted it. 7.3 still getting it so will die in my hands.
GM has changed, buddies bought them over last ten years most of them being warranty and failure prone queens, you found a good one would hang onto it.

Jonathan Baker (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 1:08AM

Ive only owned Chevy and GMC since I was 18 years old. And like you doc, i've basically had all the models :88 chev, 05 chev, 2010 chevy and currently a 2015 GMC. The only issues I've had knock on wood, is really the alternator and idler pulls going out at separate times in my 2015. But hell, she's 10 years old cause I bought here in 2014. That ain't bad. Love the GMC company and wouldn't buy anything different!

Jared Fondren (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 6:26AM

I have a 2019 GMC Sierra AT4. It has the 6.2L, 10 speed, 120K miles. Ive had no issues. I did notice a little bit of rust the frame but its from living in Kansas and the brine they put on the road in the winter time. I cleaned and coated the rust with some farm and implement. I used the method on my other cars and it took care of the rust. I plan on keeping it for the next 10 to 20 years. If the engine or tranny acts up down the road ill just replace whichever went bad and keep deiving it. Its paid for. Best truck ive ever owned. All kinds of power. Decent gas miliage.

Rt81 (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 6:35AM

It feels like this article should say paid endorsement by GM. You start with a guy who hasn't had any problems with his less than a year old truck, it could be a month old for all we know. Like this is some sort of testament to the improvement and quality. These trucks have had major possible in the last several years, not small warranty issues. Lifters are major, tranmission replacement at 40 to 80k miles for $65k trucks. Your answer is to pay $3k more for a warranty because the product sucks, or that they're built to let but also expect major repairs. You can't say both. GM doesn't even stand behind them. My mom's 22 Sierra left her stranded in Kansas in January and they would not pay for rental, towing or the payment. 15k lifter failure. Had to walk in freezing nowhere. Brothers 19' Denali Sierra lifters and transmission both below 70k miles. He's a meticulous mechanic. These trucks are garbage and you cover for them. Other trucks suck too, but you covering for them just puts consumers at risk because there's no accountability. My Hyundai needed a new motor. I had found some bearing shavings in my oil. They said no problem, new motor, rental, paid my payment the whole time it was in the shop. On a $30k car. Be better GM.

William Wilson (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 7:15AM

I purchased a 2021 GMC Sierra with less than 60K on it. After a year, my tranmission is completely shoot. My brother in law in a different state owns a Sierra and he experienced the same thing. GMC should do a complete recall and fix these at their cost. Plus, I owe 20K

Richard (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 7:50AM

I own a 2020 gmc 5.3 and after owning it about 3 years, 60k miles the transmission went out. I've always had issues with the info system unit. The back up camera freezes up alot. The whole info system sometimes takes time to just turn on. You might have to turn off the truck wait a while and turn it back on. I still own the truck. I stay on top of the maintenance.

Cincy Wildman (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 8:10AM

I have owned Chevrolet's since my first one which was a '94 Chevy 1500 short bed 350 stick shift. I use the red line 4th gear to hit 5th gear going downhill. I raced Motocross all around the country. Pulling trailers, this truck didn't have any issues.
I traded it in and bought a '97 Chevy extended cab 1500. I drove it until it died around 150,000. It died because of rust. It became a landscape It plowed snow/salted for 13 seasons.
I purchased 2005 Chevy 2500. I had it for 10 years. The second thousand miles that I put on it was a Christmas snow 2004 /2005 in Cincinnati. 3 in of ice, 8 in of snow. 2 in of ice on top of that. It did great that year along with the next nine.
I traded that truck in and bought a 2013 I drove it for 3 years plowing snow working landscaping and I traded it in because it was a lemon. It had a bunch of issues. I bought a 2015 2500 and I worked it for 10 years. Mind you my daughter plays travel softball so one weekend I'd be in Chicago another weekend. I'd be in Cleveland and another weekend. I'd be in Atlanta, Georgia for softball tournaments and through the week it pulled a trailer and during the winter is it plowed snow. It just died 2 days after Thanksgiving 2024. The transmission went out. This truck had 266,000 miles on it. The only thing things I ever had to replace on it was a radiator because of a rock, an EVAP sensor, exhaust manifolds because I start it up and shut it down 30 times a day so that was expected and just at 260,000, mi. I had to replace the brake booster. This truck plowed snow would have four tons of salt in the back. A 500 lb salt box, 500 lb of calcium and a 1000 lb plow on the front of it for 10 years and pull the trailer every single day through the work week.
Now I'm getting ready to buy a new one and I'm debating on getting a diesel or a gas motor which is what I've had on all my prior trucks.

In conclusion: I know many fellow landscapers like myself. I've watched Dodges fall on their faces and Fords have many problems. The people that have Chevys seem to have the most trouble-free vehicles in the business.

If you don't maintain your truck, it will not last long. I always joke that a chevy truck will always get you from a to b. Nothing major goes down but you can expect door handle to brake the wiper motor to go out like in the '05 model. The cluster May mess up but they're all minor problems. Nothing major ever goes wrong. I've driven almost a million miles in a Chevrolet truck and I rarely have a complaint.

Hank Koster (not verified)    December 9, 2024 - 1:08PM

I have a 2020 Silverado with 5.3 liter engine and 8 speed transmission. I bought it used at 11,000 miles and I'm now at 70,000 miles. My only maintenence so far was a transmission fluid change at 30,000 miles. I use Mobile 1 oil, which I change myself every 7,500 miles. I have had zero problems with my truck.