Get a Used 3-Row 2024 EQS 580 For The Price of Kia and Luxury That's Unparalleled To Tesla

A few days ago, while scrolling through the Mercedes-Benz EQS/EQS SUV Facebook group, I stumbled upon an intriguing post from Srikanth Katrue. His post read, "Hello everyone, what has been your maintenance on EQS SUV first few years? My wife is debating between EQS 580 SUV three-row vs Kia EV9 vs Tesla Model X. Any help is appreciated." His question sparked a lively debate among group members, and the responses provided an insightful perspective on the real-world ownership experiences of these three electric SUVs.

For anyone considering a high-end, three-row EV, the choices can be dizzying. Srikanth’s dilemma is understandable—how do you choose between the futuristic luxury of a Mercedes-Benz EQS 580, the family-friendly practicality of a Kia EV9, and the cutting-edge tech and performance of the Tesla Model X? Let’s break it down, starting with the community’s responses.

Real-World Advice from EQS, Tesla, and Kia Owners

Sam Elenia weighed in with a compelling perspective, saying, "Get a used 3-row 2024 EQS 580 for the price of Kia and luxury that's unparalleled to Tesla. Tesla is more fun to drive though. I went from Model X to Model S and now EQS 580. I also advise that you try to rent an EQS and Model X for 24 hours. My wife prefers Tesla for reasons that I can't comprehend while I prefer EQS and I dislike Tesla. I would get a 2024 EQS over the 2023 mostly because of the brakes glitch and a little bit more miles."

Jo Ki added an emphatic take: "You really can’t compare the three. Only one of those is a luxury vehicle. Depends on what you want, but if it’s luxury, then it’s Mercedes."

Meanwhile, Christopher Barclay shared a more nuanced view: "Have her drive the 580, then it will be easy as the other two are a step down in luxury and comfort. We just got rid of our Teslas and bought a 2024 EQE SUV and EQS. Could not be happier. After coming from Tesla, I had forgotten what good service was. My Tesla was not a good experience."

Sam Fran chimed in, "Definitely EQS 580. I had a Tesla and switched to EQS 580. It's a great car. My partner has Kia and the ride is not the same as EQS. You can't compare it."

Interestingly, Pakman Pak offered a balanced viewpoint: "I have both the EQS and the Rivian R1S. Both are awesome in their own way." And Grayson Ang, a moderator, brought up an important consideration for budget-conscious buyers: "EV9 will probably be more reliable and cheaper to repair out of warranty."

So, what should Srikanth and others in a similar position consider when choosing among these three impressive electric SUVs? Here’s a deeper dive into their pros and cons.

The Mercedes-Benz EQS 580 SUV: A Pinnacle of Electric Luxury

Advantages:

• Unparalleled Luxury: The EQS 580 is essentially a rolling suite, with materials and craftsmanship that scream opulence. The Hyperscreen—a massive, 56-inch display that spans the dashboard—is a tech marvel. Learn more about how this incredible screen transforms the driving experience in our in-depth review of the EQS’s infotainment system here.
• Comfort and Quietness: Air suspension and exceptional cabin insulation make for a whisper-quiet, smooth ride.
• Three-Row Versatility: While not as spacious as some competitors, the third row is adequate for children or short trips.
• Service and Build Quality: Many owners praise Mercedes for providing a level of service that Tesla often struggles to match.

Disadvantages:

• Price: Even used, the EQS 580 commands a premium. Repairs out of warranty could also be costly.
• Complexity: Advanced tech can mean more potential issues down the road.

The Kia EV9: Practical and Packed with Features

Advantages:

• Affordability: The EV9 offers impressive value for money, with a starting price significantly below the EQS 580 and Model X. Kia's investment in EVs is clearly paying off, and the EV9 has even begun to surpass the brand's popular Telluride in appeal. Discover how the EV9 is redefining Kia's electric future in our detailed analysis here.
• Warranty: Kia’s industry-leading warranty provides peace of mind for new buyers.
• Family-Oriented Design: With spacious seating, a modern interior, and an intuitive infotainment system, the EV9 is built for practicality.
• Reliability: As Grayson noted, the EV9 is likely to be cheaper to repair and more reliable out of warranty.

Disadvantages:

• Luxury Deficit: While well-equipped, it doesn’t match the EQS in terms of materials or overall refinement.
• Performance: It’s capable but lacks the exhilarating acceleration of the EQS 580 or Tesla Model X.

The Tesla Model X: Futuristic and Fun

Advantages:

• Performance: The Model X’s Plaid version accelerates like a rocket, reaching 0-60 mph in as little as 2.5 seconds.
• Tech Leadership: Tesla’s Autopilot and Full Self-Driving capabilities remain unmatched, at least in theory.
• Charging Network: Tesla’s Supercharger network provides unparalleled convenience for road trips.

Disadvantages:

• Build Quality: Tesla often comes under fire for inconsistent panel gaps and interior materials.
• Service Woes: Multiple owners, including Christopher, highlighted poor service experiences.
• Luxury Gap: Despite its price, the Model X doesn’t quite deliver the luxury feel of the EQS.

For Srikanth, it ultimately comes down to priorities. If luxury and refinement are top priorities, the Mercedes EQS 580 SUV is hard to beat. If practicality and budget take precedence, the Kia EV9 offers excellent value. And for those who crave cutting-edge tech and thrilling performance, the Tesla Model X remains a strong contender.

What do you value most in a three-row electric SUV? Would you choose the opulent Mercedes EQS 580, the reliable Kia EV9, or the tech-savvy Tesla Model X? Join the conversation and share your thoughts below,

Armen Hareyan is the founder and the Editor in Chief of Torque News. He founded TorqueNews.com in 2010, which since then has been publishing expert news and analysis about the automotive industry. He can be reached at Torque News Twitter, Facebook, Linkedin, and Youtube. He has more than a decade of expertise in the automotive industry with a special interest in Tesla and electric vehicles.