Skip to main content

The 10 Most Reliable Car Brands, Subaru Ranks 8th Best

Which car brands make the most reliable cars? I'll examine a new report from Consumer Reports and fill you in on the ten best automakers and what it means for Subaru customers. 

Are Subaru vehicles reliable?

According to a new report from Consumer Reports (by subscription), the Subaru brand of vehicles ranks in the top ten most reliable automakers. This ranking, the first-ever brand ranking for used cars, is a significant milestone in the automotive industry. 

It's not a surprise that Lexus ranks number one, and Toyota ranks number two overall. Subaru ranks 8th in the updated Consumer Reports report. Read my longest-lasting car report here

This updated ranking from Consumer Reports is its first-ever brand ranking for used cars. It's focused on the reliability of 5- to 10-year-old models, a period that's crucial for buyers. 

The ranking is based on a comprehensive analysis of various factors, including the frequency of repairs, the severity of those repairs, and the cost of ownership. It reveals to buyers how they can reduce their risks of experiencing problems by focusing on some brands over others.

Consumer Reports says, "Brands like Lexus and Toyota have a history of conservative redesigns, incrementally improving their entire product line, rather than introducing many all-new systems," says Steven Elek, Consumer Reports' senior automotive data analyst.

I like the new brand ranking for used cars. For this analysis, they use 5- to 10-year-old models. At the same time, its new car reliability ranking is based on CR's analysis of the latest three years of reliability, along with brand history and factors such as shared componentry.  

Before I look at individual Subaru model reliability, I've listed the top ten automakers and the Consumer Reports ranking score for each.

CR says, "Our data consistently shows over time that cars from these brands are reliable when new, and they continue to be reliable as they age."

  1. Lexus 75
  2. Toyota 72
  3. Mazda 59 
  4. Acura 57
  5. Honda 55
  6. Buick 47
  7. BMW 46
  8. Subaru 46
  9. Nissan 45
  10. Mercedes-Benz 43

So, why are Lexus and Toyota consistently ahead of the rest? 

According to Consumer Reports senior automotive data analyst Steven Elek, it's not just Subaru's approach to product development that contributes to its high reliability scores. It's also the brand's commitment to quality, its use of durable materials, and its rigorous testing and inspection processes. These factors, along with others, contribute to Subaru's high reliability scores.

"Brands like Lexus and Toyota have a history of conservative redesigns, incrementally improving their entire product line, rather than introducing many all-new systems," says Consumer Reports' senior automotive data analyst Steven Elek.

The longer-term life cycle of its vehicles is the unique approach that Subaru Corporation is taking now. Instead of its typical five-year product life cycle when its vehicle gets a complete remodel, Subaru is now waiting longer. The new next-generation 2025 Forester went six years, and the Outback will now go seven years between redesigns

What are Subaru's most reliable models?

Consumer Reports 2024 Subaru models ranked from best to worst, and the reliability score was 0 to 100. 

  • 2024 Subaru Crosstrek (99) 
  • 2024-2025 Subaru Forester (82)
  • 2024 Subaru WRX (78)
  • 2024 Subaru BRZ (76)
  • 2024 Subaru Impreza (69)
  • 2024 Subaru Outback (50)
  • 2024 Subaru Ascent (49)
  • 2023 Subaru Solterra (47)
  • 2024 Subaru Legacy (47)

The redesigned 2024 Subaru Crosstrek subcompact SUV nearly has a perfect score of 100 compared with other new cars. The Forester compact SUV is the other standout model, with a score in the 80s. The surprise model is the WRX performance sports car that gets a high score and is now a recommended model by Consumer Reports.

How does Subaru rank with mainstream (non-luxury) car brands? 

When you take out the luxury brand rankings, Subaru moves to the top five mainstream car brands and to fourth overall. Here are the top ten mainstream automakers. 

  1. Toyota 72
  2. Mazda 59 
  3. Honda 55
  4. Subaru 46
  5. Nissan 45
  6. Volkswagen 41
  7. Hyundai 38
  8. Chevrolet 38
  9. Kia 38
  10. Ford 36

Which Subaru will be the most likely to go 250,000 miles and beyond?

A new report from iSeeCars shows that the Subaru Outback makes the top twenty longest-lasting SUVs, which is better than average.

The average SUV has a 7.8% chance of lasting 250,000 plus miles. Some have up to a 36% chance of reaching a quarter million miles. The Subaru Outback, ranking among the top 20 longest-lasting SUVs at number twenty, surpasses the average and is a testament to its exceptional longevity. 

"We've come to expect models like the Toyota Sequoia and 4Runner to lead the Longest-Lasting SUVs list," said Brauer. "Seeing smaller SUVs like the Honda CR-V, Toyota RAV4, and Subaru Outback offering better-than-average lifespans confirms both their high-quality execution and their owners' willingness to drive these vehicles for many years and many miles."

Which five-year-old SUVs are the most reliable for shoppers this year? 

According to a recently updated Consumer Reports ranking, there are dependable used SUVs you should put on your list. CR says the 2018 Subaru Outback ranks among the nine best and scores higher than two popular Toyota SUVs. More information on buying a used Outback can be found in my report here.

Note: Make sure you check out any used Subaru model with a certified Subaru technician before you buy it.

When shopping for any used vehicle, including a Subaru, following KBB's advice is crucial. 

KBB says, "Look for well-kept models with good service history and an accident-free report, and even these sub-$5,000 SUVs can keep you on the road for years to come. However, with a vehicle this age, you may want to get a used car inspection from a mechanic before you buy to ensure you're making a sound investment."

Do you have a Subaru Outback, Forester, or other Subaru vehicle that's been the most reliable? If so, click the red Add New Comment link below and let us know.

I am Denis Flierl, a Senior Torque News Writer since 2012. I’ve invested over 13 years in the automotive industry in a consulting role, working with every major car brand. I am an experienced Rocky Mountain Automotive Press member. You'll find my expert Subaru analysis here. Follow me on my X SubaruReportAll Subaru, WRXSTI, @DenisFlierlFacebook, and Instagram.

Photo credit: Brewster Subaru

Comments

Gail Riley (not verified)    August 28, 2024 - 7:59PM

I've owned my 2011 Subaru Outback since 9/2010. It currently has around 80,000 miles on it. Without a doubt, it is the best car I've ever own over my 58 years of driving cars. It has never broken down. It has only required routine maintenance, new tires after 10 years, and new brakes. I hope it does go to 250,000 miles, which would mean it would last the rest of my life!

John M. (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 12:52PM

In reply to by Alan K (not verified)

I agree that Subi’s were more reliable before they started to use CVT transmissions. I had a 3.6 Outback with a normal auto tranny and loved it (except for its very soft suspension, especially in the curves, where it seemed to roll over way too much).
Incidentally, I find it quite amusing that the author of this article thinks that being in 8th place is so great for Subaru! Really?? I suppose he’d believe that the Chicago White Sox being in 5th place in their division is phenomenal!!
—JM 08/29/2024

Steve (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 10:16PM

In reply to by Alan K (not verified)

Our 2012 Subaru Outback with CVT has 214K miles. It's mechanically sound. There was a problem with the CVT but it was a known issue and Subaru extended the warranty to cover it. I'd day it's been the most reliable car we've ever owned. I believe in buy it new and drive it as long as you can.

Ross (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 6:29AM

In reply to by Gail Riley (not verified)

Have owned four Subaru's since 1996, 3 Outbacks & Levorg. Currently driving 2023 Outback XT. They are tough reliable wagons that require basic maintenance.
My 1996 Outback was rear ended whilst stopped at traffic lights. I drove my Outback away, the offending driver's car was towed.

Al (not verified)    August 30, 2024 - 5:44PM

In reply to by Ross (not verified)

Same happened to our 2019 Outback, when Dodge Charger rear-ended us at 50mph during slow down on Freeway.. we were driving our Outback for another week, after that, while Charger had to be towed on a flat bed truck.

Ken Turow (not verified)    September 1, 2024 - 4:19PM

In reply to by Al (not verified)

And the same happened to me, twice! My 1997 Outback was rear ended in 2012 and my 1st 2007 Outback was reat ended in 2014. Both times I was able to drive away, although both cars were totaled out by my insurance company, but both offending vehicles needed to be towed away. I’ve owned 3 Outbacks and now have a 2024 Crosstrek. Fabulous vehicles!

Alan K (not verified)    August 28, 2024 - 11:17PM

We have a 2017 Legacy 4Cly top of the line. It's had way too many issues.
At 40K left front strut leaks. Had to be replaced. Same at 65K left back strut leak. at 50k the Satellite radio went out just makes a clicking sound loud. @90k miles the CVT Transmisson went out. Had to be replaced by Subaru. @100k miles the compressor in the A/C went bad. Needed replacing. That is just too many things to go wrong with a car. Now the car has 135K and works perfectly. I still would never get one again with those CVT transmissions. My 2012 Camry before i got rid of it at 200k only needed the serpentine belt replaced and regular wear and tear. New front Rotors, That's it. So i don't understand Subaru's high ratings with their bad CVT transmissions.

James Wright (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 8:57AM

How can BMW and Nissan be on anyone's reliability list??? BMW uses plastics that fail from age and often cost more than the car is worth to replace. Plastic intakes and hoses anyone?
And the disastrous Jatco CVT's make a once great brand worthless. They ALL fail prematurely, cannot be rebuilt, and require Nissan's propriety fluid at $20/qt every 30k fluid change just to make it to 100k. The crate replacements are back ordered and cost more than the value of the vehicle!!!

Graham Johnson (not verified)    August 30, 2024 - 9:36PM

In reply to by James Wright (not verified)

100%.... in my experience BMW make some of the unreliable cars... their extensive use of plastic engine components that fail just out of warranty is legend. Unless you buy a real M series car, the rest are overpriced boat anchors.

GARBAGE ENGINEERING...

John Smith (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 10:29AM

I have a 2019 Subaru Forester and it is going on 80k i have been following the regular maintenance schedule and so far this has been the most reliable vehicle I have had. I have driven numerous cars over my lifetime including Chev, Fords, Pontiac, dodge, Mazda to include a few and in my experience this has been by far the most enjoyable ride I have had and the most reliable to this point.

CARSRUS (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 1:30PM

Have my 8 Subaru, a 2024 Outback, lease for my 2021 Forester was over, decided on the Outback as the 2024 Forester was exactly like my 2021 ! First Subie was a 1988
Legacy wagon, had 2 more than Outback’s until first Forester in 2015 . Everyone was excellent, had a 1994 foe 15 years than gave it to our daughter her 4 years of college.
Recommend them highly ! 💥💥💥💥💥

JeAnne McKeever (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 1:31PM

I have a 2012 Outback.
I have had very good use of my car with minimal repair. I got it in 2015 I just turned 100,000 miles so had timing belt replaced. So did waterpump at same time as it is right in there and also had 100,000 on it.
I'm having issues with it now as key doesn't always want to come out easily.
Overall I love my Outback. Very happy with it.

Richard Robarts (not verified)    August 29, 2024 - 5:43PM

The only repair to my 2010 Legacy was the rear brake pads and rotors as the pad pin came loose causing severe damage. Otherwise, no problems at 125000 km!

Jason (not verified)    August 30, 2024 - 8:17AM

2014 Outback 2.5 Limited.
134K miles. Things that have gone bad or broke, etc: R rear wheel bearing, rear differential carrier bushings(oil filled), upper brake light water leak, driver lumbar support adjustment.
I have maintained the car well, going by the correct intervals and am a firm believer in preventative maintenance. No CVT issues (knock on wood) yet. I just got the new bushings for the rear diff carrier and decided to get the non oil filled- to be installed soon.
I've been pretty happy with the car 🤷‍♂️
I did rip out the HK stereo and install my own system, which is aimed at sound quality, not boom boom. I upgraded the braking to power stop front and rear pads, calipers and rotors because the factory brakes just seemed weak to me.
I've been wanting to get a new XT but am just enjoying the no car payment time for a while 🙂

Linden (not verified)    August 31, 2024 - 3:59AM

We purchased a xt outback turbo in June 2023. When we took delivery, we noticed the leather seats were badly creased. We brought this matter up with the dealership, they said they noted it, took photos and said to check at the first service as to their condition. We complained, and we were fobbed off. Some months later, there was a major oil leak in a rocker cover gasket and the transmission was noisy. They fixed the oil leak under warranty but said the noisy transmission was "normal " and refused the claim. They also said the seats were normal wear a tear, and that they would not replace them. After some negotiations, it was agreed someone from subaru australia would come and inspect our car as the inspections done by the technicians were not believed by
Subaru Australia. The group manager agreed with us that both were "not right" they have had our car on and of four weeks. We do have a loan vehicle but have found the overall treatment to us by subaru australia very poor. They dismissed our waranty claim with no due diligence and disagreed with the dealership's findings of fault with a car 12 months old and 20k ks on the clock. We have been a subaru family for years and have never encountered such apathy in protecting customer satisfaction. Do better subaru australia. Did we get a lemon?

Cynthia & Sam (not verified)    August 31, 2024 - 7:47AM

Sam has a 2001 Subaru outback with over 315,000 miles and still going strong.
He also has a 2004 Subaru Forester with 88,000 miles on it . The Forester belonged to his mom and when she passed away he inherited it. Both Subaru's are very well maintained by Sam with regular maintenance by him. Timing belts get changed at our regular mechanics shop. We are a Subie family. The boxer engines are amazing. He calls both his Subaru his Oriental Girls lololol. The 2001 Outback is still his daily driving car and going strong.

Nick (not verified)    August 31, 2024 - 1:45PM

We have a 2014 Forester 2.5 limited. We're at 108K miles with no issues beyond regular maintenance and replacement of a wheel bearing. Brake pads have only been replaced once. No headlights have needed replaced. It's been a great car reliable car.

Patricia (not verified)    September 5, 2024 - 2:43AM

I drive a 2019 Forester. In December will
be year 5 of ownership. I have had zero problems with the SUV. Prior to the Forester I owned a 2017 Crosstrek, which I miss as it was a Premium. My Forester is a basic. Should I purchase again in future I may choose another make & model since I’d like something bigger, a different color, and a Premium. This is the first time I’ve bought two same brand cars, so I might want to experience something different to change things up. Overall though, I’m pleased with Subaru quality.

Shaun Davis (not verified)    September 6, 2024 - 4:54PM

I’ve had my 1996 Legacy Outback as a daily driver for about 18 years now, and it’s coming up on 300,000 miles. My last car was a Subaru, and my next one probably will be as well.