Consumer Reports' Reliable Used Sports Car Recommendations for Under $25,000

Summer cruisers are a great way to enjoy the outdoors for car enthusiasts who do not find much fun in RVs or SUVs while on the open road. A recent Consumer Reports analysis of reliable used sports car models might just have a recommendation that is right for you.

Having Summer Fun and Avoiding Summer Disaster

The freedom of wheeling along a long stretch with the convertible top down and a leisurely mile-eating day drive has much to offer when it's just you, your car, and nothing else to anchor you to your home and your job.

However, if you have not owned a sports car in a while, it helps to know what red flags to look out for when selecting a reasonably affordable used model.

While many are drool-worthy models that can bring out the inner kid in you, you will want to avoid choosing the wrong car that could crush your summer plans…and your bank account. So, you will want to pay attention to these red flags.

Used Sports Car Red Flags

When buying a used sports car, there are several red flags to watch out for to ensure you're making a wise investment. Here are some of the key things to look for:

Unusual Modifications

• Why it's a red flag: Many sports cars are modified for better performance, but excessive or poorly executed modifications could indicate previous abuse or lack of care.
• What to check: Aftermarket parts like turbochargers, exhaust systems, or suspension components that may not have been professionally installed. If modifications aren't listed, ask about them.

Unexplained or Inconsistent Maintenance History

• Why it's a red flag: A well-maintained sports car should have a detailed service record. If the owner is unwilling or unable to provide one, it could mean the vehicle has been poorly cared for.
• What to check: Look for regular maintenance records, oil changes, and major repairs. Sports cars often require more care than standard vehicles, and a lack of documentation could be a sign of neglect.

Flood or Accident History

1. Why it's a red flag: Sports cars, especially those involved in accidents or floods, may have hidden damage that compromises performance and safety.
2. What to check: Use a vehicle history report service like Carfax for accidents, flood damage, or insurance claims. You can also visually inspect the car for signs of bodywork repair or rust.

Odd Noises or Vibration During Test Drive

• Why it's a red flag: Unusual noises or vibrations could indicate mechanical issues, such as a problem with the suspension, drivetrain, or engine.
• What to check: Take the car for a thorough test drive. Listen for strange noises like knocking, rattling, or squeaking, and pay attention to how the car handles. If something feels off, it may indicate problems that could be costly to repair.

Excessive Wear and Tear on the Interior

• Why it's a red flag: While sports cars are meant to be driven hard, excessive interior wear, such as cracked leather, worn-out seats, or faded gauges, could indicate that the car has been used more harshly than it should have been.
• What to check: Look for wear on the steering wheel, seats, pedals, and dashboard. If the sports car is older, it should show some wear, but it shouldn't be falling apart inside.

Check for Rust or Paint Issues

• Why it's a red flag: Rust or uneven paint could suggest the car has been in an accident or exposed to harsh conditions.
• What to check: Inspect the undercarriage and wheel wells for rust or corrosion. Look for signs of repainting, indicating bodywork repairs or an attempt to cover up damage.

Suspiciously Low Price

• Why it's a red flag: If the price seems too good to be true, it probably is. Low prices indicate hidden issues or an attempt to sell a problem car quickly.
• What to check: Compare prices of similar models in the area. If a car is priced significantly lower than others with similar mileage and condition, it's worth asking why. Sometimes, owners sell sports cars at a loss due to underlying mechanical issues.

Unusual Exhaust Smoke or Leaks

• Why it's a red flag: Blue or black smoke from the exhaust can indicate engine problems, and any fluid leaks under the car should be a concern.
• What to check: Start the car and check the exhaust for smoke. Also, look under the vehicle for any signs of leaking oil, coolant, or transmission fluid, which can signal expensive repairs.

Too Many Owners

• Why it's a red flag: A sports car with many previous owners could indicate that the vehicle has had problems that caused owners to sell it.
• What to check: Check the vehicle history report to see how many previous owners the car has had. Multiple owners in a short period could indicate issues with the car or its handling.

Non-Original or Missing Parts

• Why it's a red flag: Sports cars often have unique parts that enhance performance or styling. Missing or non-original parts could indicate neglect or that the car has been used in inappropriate ways.
• What to check: Ensure the car has its original parts (especially key components like the exhaust, wheels, and suspension). Missing or replaced parts may point to past issues.

Owner Avoiding or Stalling Inspections

• Why it's a red flag: If the seller is unwilling to allow an inspection by a trusted mechanic, it may be because they're hiding problems.
• What to check: Always insist on an inspection before finalizing a deal, especially for high-performance cars. If the seller hesitates or refuses, walk away.

Bad or Inconsistent Engine Sound

• Why it's a red flag: Sports cars are all about performance, and a rough-running engine can signal significant issues.
• What to check: Listen for smooth acceleration. A rough idle, ticking, or knocking sounds could indicate problems with the engine that could be costly to fix.

By being vigilant and looking for these red flags, you can avoid buying a used sports car hiding expensive problems. When in doubt, consult a professional mechanic for an inspection.

That said, here are the used sports car models that have a history of being reliable and can be found today for under $25,000.

Reliable Used Sports Cars for Under $25,000

($10,000-$15,000)

Mazda MX-5 Miata 2016

Price Range: $10,500 - $13,975

Owner Reported MPG: 32 mpg

Power: 155-hp, 2.0-liter four-cylinder engine paired with a "delightfully accurate" six-speed manual shifter.

($15,000-$20,000)

BMW 4 Series 2018

Price Range: $13,175 - $20,450

Owner Reported MPG: 25 mpg

Power: Models with the 2.0-liter four-cylinder turbo are sparing with fuel; however, the 3.0-liter six-cylinder turbo is super smooth with effortless go.

Ford Mustang 2017

Price Range: $12,200 - $42,400

Owner Reported MPG: 20 mpg

Power: Turbocharged four-cylinder engine.

Mazda MX-5 Miata 2020

Price Range: $14,650 - $20,900

Owner Reported MPG: 32 mpg

Power: Turbocharged four-cylinder that is a bit gaspy at low-engine RPMs, but it ramps up rapidly as the revs build.

($20,000-$25,000)

Audi A5 2019

Price Range: $16,475 - $25,850

Owner Reported MPG: 27 mpg

Power: The A5 gets a 2.0-liter turbocharged four-cylinder engine matched to a seven-speed dual-clutch automatic transmission. However, a sportier choice is an S5 version powered by a 3.0-liter turbo V6 mated to an eight-speed automatic.

BMW 4 Series 2019

Price Range: $15,950 - $26,775

Owner Reported MPG: 25 mpg

Power: A 3.0-liter turbocharged inline six-cylinder engine with an eight-speed automatic is standard; however, a six-speed manual is a no-cost option.

Mazda MX-5 Miata 2022

Price Range: $17,650 - $25,625

Owner Reported MPG: 33 mpg

Power: A peppy 2-liter 4-cylinder engine with 181 hp mated with either a 6-speed manual or optional automatic.

Mini Cooper 2022

Price Range: $15,575 - $30,575

Owner Reported MPG: 27 mpg

Power: The Cooper S uses a 189-hp turbo four-cylinder and a six-speed manual, but it also has the standard 134-hp, 1.5-liter turbo three-cylinder engine, which is surprisingly energetic.

If you are in the market for a new sports car rather than a used one, click on the link "The Most Underrated Sports Car You Can Buy In 2025."

Timothy Boyer is an automotive reporter based in Cincinnati who currently researches and works on restoring older vehicles with engine modifications for improved performance. He also reports on modern cars (including EVs) with a focus on DIY mechanics, buying and using tools, and other related topical automotive repair news. Follow Tim on Twitter at @TimBoyerWrites as well as on Facebook and his automotive blog "Zen and the Art of DIY Car Repair" for useful daily news and topics related to new and used cars and trucks.

COMING UP NEXT: Is It Safe To Keep A Portable Jump Starter In Your Car? "I Keep Mine In My Wife's Toyota RAV4 All The Time."

Image Source: Deposit Photos