I Test Drove The Tesla Model Y Several Times and Bought The Ioniq 5. Here's The Difference

Tesla, often viewed as the gold standard for electric vehicles, has built a loyal following with its innovative technology, impressive performance, and extensive Supercharger network. However, as more automakers enter the EV space, the options available to buyers have grown significantly, bringing new contenders that challenge Tesla's dominance. One such competitor is Hyundai, with its Ioniq 5, which has been turning heads with its fresh design and robust features.

A reader of Torque News, who goes by the name Cat, recently shared her personal experience in the comments section of an article comparing the Tesla Model 3 with the Hyundai Ioniq 6. Cat test-drove the Tesla Model Y multiple times before ultimately deciding to purchase the Hyundai Ioniq 5. Her insights provide a valuable perspective for potential EV buyers who may be weighing similar options. Let’s dive into Cat’s reasons for choosing the Ioniq 5 over the Tesla Model Y and explore what sets these two vehicles apart.

"I test drove the Tesla Model Y several times and bought the Ioniq 5. It was a smoother ride, more intuitive controls, and the interior was better built. The Tesla lane assist would yank me into the center of the lane whereas Hyundai uses firm, but gentle pressure. Additionally, Teslas are long overdue for a redesign, they looked cutting edge in 2012 and very similar ever since; the Ioniq lineup demonstrates Hyundai is doing more exciting things with their designs," Cat wrote comparing the Model Y with the Ioniq 5.

Ioniq 5 Has a Smoother Ride Compared the Model Y

Cat’s first notable observation was the difference in ride quality between the Tesla Model Y and the Hyundai Ioniq 5. While Tesla is known for its strong acceleration and sharp handling, Cat found the Ioniq 5 to offer a smoother and more comfortable ride. The Ioniq 5’s suspension system seems to have been engineered with an emphasis on absorbing road imperfections and delivering a more relaxed driving experience. This is a crucial factor for drivers who prioritize comfort, especially on long trips or daily commutes.

In contrast, the Tesla Model Y, while undoubtedly thrilling to drive with its quick acceleration and responsive steering, can sometimes feel stiffer. For drivers like Cat, who value a plush ride, the Ioniq 5’s ability to glide over bumps and uneven road surfaces made a significant difference in her overall driving experience.

Ioniq 5's Intuitive Controls and Interior Quality vs That Of Tesla Model Y

Another area where the Ioniq 5 stood out to Cat was in its interior design and controls. EV enthusiasts often discuss the minimalist approach Tesla takes with its interior, relying heavily on a central touchscreen to control most vehicle functions. While this design is sleek and modern, it can be a bit overwhelming for some drivers, particularly those who prefer more tactile controls and easy access to essential functions without navigating through multiple screen menus.

Cat found the Ioniq 5’s controls to be more intuitive and user-friendly. Hyundai has struck a balance between modern tech and traditional buttons, offering a layout that is both functional and aesthetically pleasing. The physical buttons and knobs in the Ioniq 5 provide a level of immediacy and familiarity that can be reassuring, especially when making adjustments on the go.

Interior quality also played a role in Cat’s decision. She felt that the Ioniq 5 had a better-built interior, with materials and craftsmanship that exude a sense of quality. The spacious cabin, comfortable seats, and attention to detail in the Ioniq 5’s design contributed to an environment that felt more premium compared to the Model Y. For many buyers, the tactile experience of a well-crafted interior is just as important as the vehicle’s performance or tech features.

Lane Assist and Driving Assistance: A Gentler Approach

One of the standout features in modern EVs is the suite of driver assistance technologies, including lane assist systems. Cat noted a significant difference between the lane assist functionality in the Tesla Model Y and the Hyundai Ioniq 5. Tesla’s system is known for its assertive approach, often described as “yanking” the vehicle into the center of the lane. This can be jarring for some drivers, especially those who prefer a more subtle intervention.

The Ioniq 5, on the other hand, employs a gentler touch. According to Cat, the Hyundai’s lane assist uses firm but smooth pressure to keep the vehicle centered in the lane, offering a more comfortable and less intrusive driving experience. This is a critical distinction for drivers who want the safety benefits of lane-keeping technology without feeling like they’re battling the system. The Ioniq 5’s approach provides a sense of security while maintaining a more natural driving feel.

Design: A Fresh Take vs. a Familiar Face

Tesla’s design language, characterized by sleek lines and a minimalist aesthetic, was groundbreaking when the Model S first appeared on the scene over a decade ago. However, as Cat pointed out, Tesla’s vehicles have largely retained the same design cues since then, with relatively minor updates. While this consistency appeals to many, others may feel that Tesla’s look has become somewhat dated, particularly in a rapidly evolving automotive market.

Hyundai’s Ioniq lineup, including the Ioniq 5, represents a bold departure from traditional design norms. The Ioniq 5’s retro-futuristic styling, with its sharp angles, distinctive LED lighting, and pixel-inspired details, makes it a head-turner on the road. Cat appreciated Hyundai’s willingness to push the envelope with design, offering something truly different and exciting in a sea of EVs that often prioritize function over form.

For buyers who crave a fresh and unique look, the Ioniq 5’s design could be a significant selling point. It’s a vehicle that stands out not just as an EV, but as a statement of modern automotive design.

Cat’s experience highlights the importance of considering all aspects of a vehicle before making a purchase. While Tesla remains a dominant force in the EV market, it’s clear that competitors like the Hyundai Ioniq 5 are offering compelling alternatives that address different priorities and preferences. From a smoother ride and intuitive controls to a more refined interior and distinctive design, the Ioniq 5 provides an appealing package for those who value these attributes.

For prospective EV buyers, Cat’s story is a reminder that the best choice depends on what you value most in a vehicle. Whether it’s the futuristic tech and raw performance of a Tesla or the comfort, craftsmanship, and innovative design of a Hyundai, the growing diversity in the EV market means there’s likely a perfect match for everyone. Ultimately, the key is to test drive, explore your options, and choose the vehicle that feels right for you.

What is your opinion about the Tesla Model Y vs either the Ioniq 5 or Ioniq 6? Please, join the discussion below by clicking the red link under this article.

Armen Hareyan is the founder and the Editor in Chief of Torque News. He founded TorqueNews.com in 2010, which since then has been publishing expert news and analysis about the automotive industry. He can be reached at Torque News Twitter, Facebook, Linkedin, and Youtube. He has more than a decade of expertise in the automotive industry with a special interest in Tesla and electric vehicles.