I Recently Took My 2021 Rav4 LE AWD In For A Check Engine Light. I've Been Waiting To Hear Back From Them And Just Saw The Updated Quote. Apparently, A Damaged Fuel Line Requires The Entire Fuel System Assembly To Be Replaced. This Can't Be Legit…Is It?

A recent forum topic in the Rav4 World social media interest group generated by OP Adam-K raises an interesting question about fuel lines on cars: Should you ever decide to have them repaired instead of replaced?

Here is a summary of the OP's problem that led to this question:

The OP had a check engine light warning in his 2012 Rav4 LE that triggered diagnostic codes p0455 and p0441. The codes indicate a problem with the vehicle's evaporative control emission system.

The cause of the code triggering could be something as simple as a gas cap that is not seated properly and is leaking vapors from the gas tank. It could also be a faulty gas vapor purge valve that needs replacing. In either case, both problems are simple DIY repairs.

For more about this repair, here is a short video explaining what to do:

P0455 Code Explained! How to Fix Your EVAP Leak Fast

When It's Not a Gas Cap or Purge Valve Problem

A worst-case scenario, however, is that there could be a leak somewhere within the fuel system lines, which could cause fuel to leak or spray under pressure near a hot engine or exhaust.

Unfortunately for the OP, what at first was thought to be a simple fix turned out to be a hole in the fuel line caused by a rodent gnawing on it.

I recently took my 2021 Rav4 LE AWD in for a check engine light. I was getting p0455 and p0441. Replaced gas cap and they determined it was the evaporative purge valve. I've been waiting to hear back from them and just saw the updated quote. Apparently, a damaged fuel line requires the entire fuel system assembly to be replaced. This can't be legit is it?

Any ideas on trying to repair hose without having to replace entire unit? Apparently, it's all fused together per the dealer.

Important Fuel Line Considerations

A helpful response from one commenter addresses the repair possibility but leans more heavily on the side of caution pointing out that a leaking fuel line is a serious problem and is best handled with a replacement of the fuel system as diagnosed and quoted in the garage estimate.

Gas leaks are dangerous and something you want to fix correctly without screwing around with a Mickey Mouse repair…You don't want that fuel or vapor to be blown back on the hot muffler when the RAV4 is driving ―Tazio Nuvolari

I'd bite the bullet and get the dealer repair. Invest in some peppermint spray, rodent poison, and mouse traps on the floor under your RAV when you park at night.

A Less Expensive Solution is Found

However, a $3,700 repair bill is a big bullet to bite.

Fortunately, the OP found a solution to the problem by going to another garage that recommended salvaging a fuel system from a junked Rav4. Their estimate was almost $3,000 cheaper!

I ended up just taking it to a Japanese auto shop and had them install a used tank from another 21 Rav4. Both the mechanics and myself were quite surprised how little damage there was to the evap line causing the issue. Anyway, $750 seemed reasonable for a new tank and install, and the problem is gone.

What Would You Have Done?

Avoiding the temptation of (for lack of a better word at the moment)―a redneck repair―the right choice was looking for a solution beyond buying a "Weld-All" squeeze tube gel or other similar product to seal the hole in the fuel line.

A better but still questionable solution would have been to cut and splice in a repair, hoping that aircraft-grade hose clamps would prevent fuel leakage.

In other words, just as there is a right tool for the right job, there is also the right repair for a safe and acceptable fix.

The OP's decision to salvage a fuel system from a junked Rav4 is acceptable and saved him thousands of dollars.

However, the OP's Rav4 is only 4 years old and probably will last many more years. An argument can be made that considering the value of the 2021 Rav4, replacing the fuel line with a new OEM part (with a guarantee backing it) may still have been a better option and choice.

It's a judgment call.

Tell Us What You Think: Have you ever made a judgment call on your vehicle's repair and regretted choosing the less expensive option?

Let us know about it in the comments section below.

COMING UP NEXT: I'm Considering Buying a 2015 Prius With 68k Miles. At The Dealership, I Insisted That The Service Staff Check On The Battery Fan Filter. It Was Pretty Dirty. The Owner Hadn't Cleaned It In 10 Years. Is This a Red Flag In a 2015 Prius?

Timothy Boyer is an automotive reporter based in Cincinnati who currently researches and works on restoring older vehicles with engine modifications for improved performance. He also reports on modern cars (including EVs) with a focus on DIY mechanics, buying and using tools, and other related topical automotive repair news. Follow Tim on Twitter at @TimBoyerWrites as well as on Facebook and his automotive blog "Zen and the Art of DIY Car Repair" for useful daily news and topics related to new and used cars and trucks.