Skip to main content

I Bought A 2023 Toyota Tacoma TRD Off-road, But Now, I Am Thinking Of Going Back To A 2019 Model, Because Of These Issues

Owners knock on Toyota's reliability as Tacomas, less than two years old, are experiencing unusual problems. But are owners right to be upset, or can some of it be negligence?

As someone who is following what goes on in Toyota's kitchen, I am curious to learn about the experience of other owners. Toyota Tacoma is, currently, the most popular midsize truck in the US, despite some owners reporting various issues. That said, it appears the third-generation isn't without its faults either as my latest find on ToyotaNation.com discovered.

An older thread regarding 2023 Tacoma transmission issues is being revisited by members, and since, it has become a thread for various other issues that plague the Toyota truck. The latest addition is from March 4, 2025, where a member speaks of various issues that have become so annoying that he is considering (for the first time ever) changing the brand. Here's what deross68 says:  

“I love Toyota. I've owned the corolla, Camry Solara, Tacoma. Loved! 2019 Tacoma had a smaller screen than my phone was annoying. Bought my 2023 TRD Off-road and man do I regret it. Kinda stuck seeing the latest issues they're acknowledging with their newer models. Hope they get it together as I'm ready to get a better, less needy truck. #disappointed. 

First the bearing in my tailgate fails, little plastic bearing btw. Had to pay out of pocket although numerous postings of the same issue. Next, a message to bring to dealer asap for sensor issues, just cleared the code and again out of pocket. Transmission lags at random, of course not while being serviced therefore out of pocket again. Now I'm receiving messages that my battery is low. 2023 has 17,400 miles. Willing to bet this is out of my pocket too. I'm about to trade back down to a 2019. Ridiculous.” 

It seems the third-generation Toyota Tacoma continues to suffer from a variety of issues, even in its last model year. 

According to RepairPal, the 2023 Toyota Tacoma has a reliability rating of 3.5 out of 5, which is average for the midsize pickup truck segment, and far below the average for a Toyota. I recently reported on another Tacoma issue, this time a 2022 model, which isn't as serious at first glance but still enough to worry truck owners who depend on their Toyota to always perform. Traditionally, late model years are less prone to issues than their early counterparts, but it seems this may not be the case for the third-generation Tacoma. 

While some of these are known to be common issues for the 2023 Toyota Tacoma (like the sensor issues), it seems dealers are not willing to fix them under warranty, at least according to this owner. There are 25 common problems found on the 2023 Toyota Tacoma, but the plastic tailgate bearing is not among them. 

Some owners blame Tacoma's reliability on the manufacturing process 

Here are some issues that 2023 Toyota Tacoma ownwes are experiencing

To be more specific, many owners blame the fact that since 2005, some Toyota Tacoma variants have been built in Mexico - Apaseo El Grande and Tijuana. The third-generation Tacoma is also built in San Antonio, Texas, but only until 2021, so if you have a 2023 Toyota Tacoma, it is built in Tijuana, Mexico. Whether that's the main culprit for the reliability issues is academic at this point, but let's see what other owners are saying. 

Toto says: “At least some Tacomas have been made in Mexico since the beginning of Gen 2 or 2005. Some parts for all Tacomas (including the composite bed) were made in Mexico and shipped to the plant in the US where other Tacomas were made. 
COVID affected the quality of everything. I think all cars have suffered since then." 

Deross68 adds: “I agree. Mine was actually made in Mexico. I ordered it and watched its delivery progress online as it came via ship across the ocean. I was ready to upgrade as I'm not impressed with this truck. Unfortunately, they're now having transmission issues. I'm just waiting it out for now. 
I get it about the battery. I think it's odd to have battery issues already, but I guess I shouldn't be surprised. Nothing is made to last long nowadays. Soon we'll plugging them in anyhow”. 

Some of these problems are becoming more common and plaguing even newer generations, after less than a year of ownership. Even some 2024 Toyota Tacoma owners are experiencing battery issues, among others. 

The owner and thread-started mentions that he also uses LoJack, which is an aftermarket add-on system that utilizes GPS to help locate the vehicle in case it is stolen. 

Toto says: “Lojack is an aftermarket add-on that draws power, so maybe it's part of the reason why there's a battery issue. 
 
Batteries are made by maybe three companies in North America. No car maker makes their own batteries. And batteries are not exactly a precision piece of equipment. They're very much luck-of-the-draw these days.” 

The FAQ section on LoJack's website claims that the unit may draw a very small amount from your vehicle's battery power. Seeing that the product reviews are generally positive, it seems unlikely that this is the culprit.  

What are your thoughts on Toyota's quality in the past few years? Between the new Toyota V-6 engine having issues, does this shake your trust in the Japanee brand? If you own a newer Toyota model, I would love to hear your thoughts. Feel free to drop a line or two in the comment section below so we can have more informative and helpful content for future owners.  

Dimitar Angelov's automotive interests made him an expert in a wide variety of vehicles. Japanese brands like Toyota are closest to his heart, although performance cars in general are his favorite segment, which is why he is constantly on the lookout for the best deals on the market. Dimitar Angelov's car passion and knack for the written word led him to complete a Master of Arts in Media and Communications and classic car restoration. Dim is happy to get behind the wheel of any car and share his impressions. You can follow Dimitar on XLinked-inInstagram, and Facebook.

Image source: 2023 Toyota Tacoma

Comments

Terri Tacoma (not verified)    March 5, 2025 - 3:53PM

He should've gotten a manual transmission. All gen 3 automatic transmissions have a lag issue as well as hunting for gears unless you get a tune, or push that button on the bottom of the dash. I have a 2022 trd offroad and my stock battery lasted 2 and a half years before it died. Theres no telling how old the battery really was. I want to know if the authors 2019 had the same setup on it as his 2023. Were they both 4x4? Both trd offroad models? Same size wheels and tires? Similar weights? Any known mods done to either? Are both trucks double cab short bed or long bed? If the 2013 was not brand new, then it had a rough early life. The tailgate was probably stolen, which I hear is popular out west. Thats probably a replacement tailgate with a cheap non oem bearing from amazon. The previous owner(if thats the case) probably didn't want to pay for an oem replacement tailgate, so either he or the body shop ordered the cheapest tailgate they could find, and either the tailgate had the bearing already in it, or they installed one. There should be no difference from 2019 to a 2023. The 2023 should be better than the 2019, and have less issue, not more. Something is not right.

Nick (not verified)    March 6, 2025 - 12:47PM

In reply to by Terri Tacoma (not verified)

All 3rd gen tacos have the lag and the hunt for gear malaise . So do most of the competitors, it was an effort to improve mpgs by thinkering with shift points . After test driving many midsize trucks , I accidentally came across a new 19 sport taco 6spd manual , test drove it for 15 min and bought it on the spot . Almost 6 yrs later , 65k miles trouble free . Got clutch pedal replaced under warranty due to squeak , and tires at 45k ( choice) all original otherwise . Still enjoying every ride .

Jim Miller (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 10:01AM

In reply to by Dimitar Angelov

I bought a 2022 trd offroad with a manual and it left me stranded twice, hours from home. Sensor issues. I bought the truck brand new.
I live in wyoming. Things like that can be a death sentence in the winter. I traded it in on a 2024 4runner. They are still made in Japan.
I love tacomas and still own a 1998 trd offoad with a manual. I will never buy another one if it's made in Mexico
I traded it in on a 2024

Shaun K (not verified)    March 6, 2025 - 5:41PM

In reply to by Terri Tacoma (not verified)

I have a manual 2019 Tacoma TRD Pro. The transmission is horrible. Clunky and after 65,000 miles the accumulator that Toyota put on it for some reason seized up and became a restrictor. I have to hit certain RPMs to get it to shift right. It now has 85,000 miles and I'll probably be replacing the transmission by the 100k mark. Very disappointing.

James Smith (not verified)    March 6, 2025 - 7:33PM

In reply to by Terri Tacoma (not verified)

I have a 23 SR5 4x4 Access cab with 6 foot bed (kind of my work truck, I put a shell on it). I have had no problems with it, have about 38,000 miles and it has been totally reliable. That said, I don't beat it, have done all the normal maintenance, and drive kind of like the old man that I am. We have many toyotas and they have all been very reliable (and boring). I am also a big fan of Mazdas, they are not so boring and nearly as reliable.

Dimitar Angelov    March 7, 2025 - 3:48AM

In reply to by Terri Tacoma (not verified)

By the looks of it, the truck was bought brand-new or new-ish (possibly a demo car). 

Something is indeed not right. I actually never thought about the possibilities of 12V batteries in new cars not being as new as the actual car they are put in.

Normally, there is a sticker on the battery indicating the date of manufacture. 

Roger Kidd (not verified)    March 6, 2025 - 8:04AM

I have a 2023 Tacoma off road
Rear diff whines, already replaced once. Still whines,said that's normal.
Put some kind of padding to cover up noise. That's BS. My frost Toyota, and my last!!!!

Ken Kingsbury (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 9:21AM

In reply to by Roger Kidd (not verified)

I had the same noise. It's not the rear differential, there is a TSB (Technical Service Bulletin) on it describing the box separating from the chassis. Covered under initial warranty but not powertrain warranty after 3 years.

Steve (not verified)    March 6, 2025 - 9:10AM

I have a 2023 toyota tacoma sport. I like the truck but hate the transmission that is always hunting to find a gearto stay in. Hill or incline are the worst. Come on toyota fix the problem. I went from a ford ranger to a toyota. I'm going back to a ranger when my warranty is up its a joke to have truck do this.

Dimitar Angelov    March 7, 2025 - 3:46AM

In reply to by Steve (not verified)

A lot of people complain about the transmissions hunting for gears. Apparently, carmakers do this for MPG purposes.

Not really a fan of how newer cars/ trucks/ SUVs are sometimes "nerfed" just so the EPA can give a better rating. You can always do a TCU remap, I suppose, though Toyota (and the other companies) should really do better, even though I know they probably won't... 

Bo Diddly (not verified)    March 6, 2025 - 7:22PM

Toyota has always had issues with their 6 cylinder motors. While not catastrophic in most cases, the issues have been there. One of the biggest I recall is leaky motors. Be it weeping or gushing on low mileage motors.
However, my 2002 V6 Tundra has been bullet-proof
In regards to batteries, LoJack should not create any issues. The draw is negligible.
There is something else going on or Toyota is using a battery that is not up to the task.

Tacoma King (not verified)    March 6, 2025 - 10:18PM

Ordered a 2022 Tacoma TRD 4X4 off road with a 6spd manual. Haven't had any issues on the 33k + miles I have put on it. I tow with it and drive long distances from time to time. I installed a Sprint Booster for better throttle response and changed out the OEM intake with an Injen system. Next will be a Magnuson supercharger. Of course I don't have the transmission issues or tailgate "bearing" problem. I'm sure it's a plastic "bushing"...not a bearing. And the battery...well they come with a lead acid battery which are not durable and do require periodic maintenance. So an upgrade to an Optima would definitely be a big improvement. And no sensor issues that I have heard of.

Louis Seirio (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 3:12AM

I have purchased a 2017 Toyota Tacoma and had nothing but problems with it The The rear end problems Cost me $7000

Hugh Mellert (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 7:18AM

Bought a 2018 Tacoma in 2022. Six speed manual transmission. After 18 had a transmission leak. Dealership replaced the front seal, at no charge. Still leaked, so they replaced the rear seal. For 6 months now, no leak. We will see how long it lasts.

John walker (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 7:27AM

We have a 2024 Grand highlander and we live south of Buffalo NY . Because of the winter weather the weak and poorly engineered bottm panels under the car fill up with salt and gravel to the point of collapsing. When they fill up the salt lays on the car . Can't be good long term. We had the same issue on our 2018 camry. This engineering can't work in a winter environment. I've owned Toyota since 1982 I'm 65 now . My family has many Toyota's. Been very disappointed as of late

Gary Hewes (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 9:12AM

My , 23 trd sport the head liner coming apart the transmission will shift down to many gears and if the temperature is 20 degrees won't shift out of 4th gear for 10 miles 4 wheel drive very grabby in parking lots or my driveway dash lights flickering exhaust rattle been to 2 different dealers everything MEETS TOYOTA STANDERS and I was also told I WAS TOLD I WILL LEARN TO DRIVE IT and Toyota engagement center was NO Help this is the only Toyota that will ever grace my driveway thank you very disappointed Gary

Ken Kingsbury (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 9:17AM

I leased a 2021 Tacoma SE and was planning to buy it at lease end, but after 3 serious issues, decided to trade it for a Honda Ridgeline. An air conditioning pipe developed a leak which their tech told me was a common problem. Then the condensor failed after only 30 months and just over 60K. Finally, there was an annoying whine above 70 km/h, so I took it in and was told this is a known issue and there is a Technical Service Bulletin on this. Apparently, the box is coming apart from the frame and the solution is to install some bushings to dull the noise, not correct the issue. This would have cost me $1,000 after tax since my full coverage warranty is up. It is covered within the first 60K warranty. I cancelled an order for a new RAV4 Prime and bought a Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV, and am enjoying a new Honda as well.

Rod (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 7:01PM

I have a 2020 TRD Sport 4x4 long box, purchased new. It has 20,000 miles and has been "Krown" undercoated 5 times since new. Aside from it hunting for the right gear because of shift points or a lack of power, i am now having trouble actually getting the shift lever to move to the "D" position. I have sprayed it numerous times and it seems to work better for a short while, then reverts back to hard shifting. Sometimes it will trigger a warning to return to dealer for engine/transmission problem.
Is this a common problem?

Dale (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 7:01PM

Had a brand new 1986, 22R 300000 miles 13 years. 30 miles to the gallon or replace power pump diaphragm in carb. Chevy S10 3 years traded at pay off steering always out of alignment. 2003 TRD toco 14 mpg 4x4. Bigger trailer, up graded to F150 Ecoboost, 16 mpg 4x4, room to spread out, and could drag 9000 pound trailer safety.

Chase (not verified)    March 7, 2025 - 7:58PM

My 21 has been flawless. Absolutely nothing has failed. My battery i just replaced with an odyssey which is early in my experience.

Kris (not verified)    March 8, 2025 - 2:24AM

I bought a 2023 Toyota Tacoma, I have taken it back 2 time already for not shifting right and it's about to go back for the 3 rd time same thing I'm very disappointed in it, they should recall them lemon law. I won't be buying another Toyota.

Ateeq Afzal (not verified)    March 8, 2025 - 4:08AM

This has got to be the most stupidest article ever written they are both third gen Tacomas with same transmission this article is stupid and misleading

Danny Odum (not verified)    March 8, 2025 - 9:07AM

My 2022 Tacoma SR5 has cabin issues. When driving 65 mph or more or if it’s a windy day it makes a wind tunnel sound,swooshing noise. Since truck is still under warranty the dealership has been troubleshooting to try to repair it but to no avail. I traded my 2003 SR5 in for this one. I like the truck and hope the problem can be solved.

David McRoy (not verified)    March 8, 2025 - 6:30PM

I bought a 2021 Tacoma TRD PRO OFF ROAD with 36000 miles. It had a terrible oil leaking. I took it to the nearest Toyota dealership. They cleaned the oil off of the skid plate and said it was ok. It kept leaking, I crawled under it and felt all around the oil pan. It was the drain plug leaking. It didn't have a washer on it.

Jason (not verified)    March 9, 2025 - 11:58AM

I own a 2019 TRD Off-Road double cab with 5ft bed. It just hit over 100k miles. I have had it tuned to help with the gear hunting. I have also put 3inch lift, bigger tires, different exhaust, and air intake. Haven’t had a single issue with it to date. It is a daily driver for me in the Seattle area and in the surrounding mountains. I don’t abuse it, but I am not gentle with it either. On weekends it’s my farm truck or I use it to get firewood.

I believe that there are more positive Tacoma reviews. The negative reviews with dealerships should fall on the dealership. Parts can be bad even brand new from the factory. Dealerships need to own up to the warranty and repair or replace what has gone bad. I have learned to do all the maintenance myself and don’t deal with dealerships anymore. Since I have started doing everything myself, I can fix any issues before they become headaches. As with anything, take care of the item and the item will take care of you.