Skip to main content

Subaru WRX STI Makes "10 Cars You Should Avoid Buying” List

According to Forbes, the 2019 Subaru WRX STI performance car is one of 10 cars you don't want to buy.

Forbes says there are 10 cars in 2019 that you do not want to buy and should avoid at all costs. The sport-tuned 2019 Subaru WRX and performance tuned WRX STI make the top cars to avoid list 2019 at number 10. Forbes says they wouldn’t recommend these cars to their friends or relatives so that means you don’t want them either.

Forbes based most of its ranking on the most-recent new-vehicle reports from Consumer Reports and dependability and initial quality scores from J.D. Power’s owner surveys. They also put weight on a number of other reviews and their own test drives.

What’s wrong with the WRX/STI?

According to Forbes, the WRX and WRX STI is basically a rally car version of the Impreza compact and you need to be a “certain disposition” to enjoy it. They say it has a “skittish demeanor” that feels underdeveloped when held up against “more sophisticated performance-minded models.”

They also say the WRX ($27,195) and WRX STI ($36,595) are too pricey compared with other models. They cite Consumer Reports giving it a low overall rating among sports cars, and poor ratings for reliability from CR and J.D. Power, ranking it below average for initial quality. Forbes says you are better off buying a Subaru BRZ, Toyota 86, or a Honda Civic Si or Type R.

Forbes top ten cars to avoid

Forbes says the new cars, trucks, and SUVs to avoid for 2019 are as follows in order of ranking from one to ten. Number one is the Alfa Romeo Giulia, followed by the Dodge Journey, Fiat 500L, Fiat 500X, Jeep Renegade, Land Rover Discovery Sport, Mitsubishi Mirage, Nissan Titan XD, Smart EQ ForTwo, and number 10, the Subaru WRX and WRX STI.

We do agree Subaru needs to get a handle on the reliability factor and quality issues the WRX STI has had. We couldn’t disagree more with Forbes on the WRX and WRX STI performance handling and overall driving dynamics. The car is for those who want a dynamic driving experience, not a refined ride. Its rally-inspired all-wheel-drive technology and Subaru turbo Boxer engine that sits low in the chassis is what sets the car apart. The 2019 Subaru WRX/STI does have some issues, but they are still the most affordable fun sports cars in the world.

You May Also Like: Is Subaru The New Extreme AWD Off-Road Brand?

Leave your comments below, share the article with friends and tweet it out to your followers!

Follow more Subaru WRX STI news on FacebookTwitter and Instagram

Photo credit: Subaru USA

Comments

Dana Francey (not verified)    May 5, 2019 - 9:54PM

Really not fair to bundle the wrx with the sti... there arent many 0 to 60 in 5.1 second cars for the price of a WRX and the wrx gets great gas mileage considering the power. AWD for safety in the snow.. OEM roof rack available to haul lumber bikes and kayaks and room for 2 kid car seats in the back... but OK guess I'll listen to the experts and buy a BRZ next...that will check off all my boxes..

George (not verified)    May 5, 2019 - 10:20PM

Consider the people who purchase ANY Hi Per sports cars...Not exact Ma PA types...Now consider ANY Hi Per car for dependability..
...Why can't they make 50k before having problems? Daaaaaah ???

Marc Maloof (not verified)    May 5, 2019 - 11:20PM

I have owned 5 Subaru's three of them being sti's and two forester XT. I hat 2006 sti stock and put on turbo back, intake and Cobb stage 2 setup. Never had any issues with it. I got my 2008 sti which was stock and did the same setup and spun a bearing. Subaru replaced my engine with a long block. I pre-order my 2016 sti and had a great experience with Subaru of Ontario. The car was exactly the way I wanted. At 7k on the car I did a turbo back exhaust, aem intake, Cobb ebc and Cobb access port. The car was then turned by yimisport. Putting down 315awhp and 328awtq. I have 37k on the car now and still feels the same and does not burn any oil. I also had a 2014 forester XT and currently I have 2018 forester XT. Subaru does have the highest resale value and i wonder why. I have never reply to any post before but saying the wrx and sti on the top 10 cars not to buy is completely wrong. If you are looking at a wrx get a sti lol jk but both cars are amazing.
Instagram @marc16sti

Marcb (not verified)    May 23, 2019 - 9:00AM

In reply to by Marc Maloof (not verified)

The sti gets horrible gas mileage though and its power delivery, stock or tuned makes it a poor daily driver compared to the wrx...I saved 10 grand, and embarrass modded sti's...On my e35 tune I make 345 awhp, and STILL get 25mpgs on the back roads...The fa20dit is just a better motor...Twin scroll turbo, and a timing CHAIN...Cant compare the wrx 6 speed to the sti obviously, but if you dont drive like an ass doing 5k launches all day, it can handle 350 awhp pretty well...Wanna go higer? Just swap out the 6 speed...I was going to trade it in for a 2021 Fa dit powered STI, but I may just save the $ and put in a used sti trans/axles...Dont need the dccd...Everyone I know with an sti has blown at least one motor up

Thidemem (not verified)    May 6, 2019 - 12:04AM

I drive my Impreza because I love to drive it, now that I read this article on Forbes magazine. I reconsidered the following, I still love driving my Impreza and I couldn't care less for Forbes. (Dare to compare a WRX with a Civic...)

Big gaz (not verified)    May 6, 2019 - 1:37AM

I built myself a 500bhp wrx import lightweight 12 years ago as i wanted a proper rally car for the road lots of mods most original parts raplaced including the addition of a straight cut gearbox it finally duffed its pistons and valves after 11 years due to the stupid pre oil filters in the banjo bolts handled great if you put good coil overs on etc not skittish pure class new stroker engine ready to go in 0 to 60 2.3 secs 0 to 100 in 6 secs what is there not to like wipe arse with supercars there shit and expensive and girly get a life haters and begrudge rs this is a mans car

Dr. Craig Walker (not verified)    May 6, 2019 - 8:30AM

The only way to own an STI is new or on lease. This way, none of its racing related damage will be hidden from you. This car is like the turbo RX Mazdas...you will be using the rev limiter as a shift point, which means they will always be driven hard and put away wet. A rally driver friend once said of the early 2.0 STI: "I could never driver it; it holds on so well, your only sense of its limit would be if you were upside down in the trees."

Ty Jurgens (not verified)    May 6, 2019 - 9:40AM

Knock knock who's there ?
Subaru bottom ends.....,I'm not a hater even after 5 engines .....it's that rumble ....hooked like a crack head from day one ....Subaru for life baby

Dustin Tarditi (not verified)    May 6, 2019 - 1:57PM

The same people recommend avoiding Jeep Wranglers because of the harsh ride, lack of creature comforts, and road noise... recommending folks to get Toyota Rav4 and Honda CRV instead.

Norman (not verified)    May 6, 2019 - 8:10PM

I drive a 2011 Subaru Legacy, it's has its issues and its has its issues. But, I was rear ended at a stop light , at an main intersection and I credit the Subaru for my safety. You should have seen the other car. I drive the Legacy hard and play with the ideal of purchasing a WRX or WRX sti. I test drove an STI and enjoyed it. The sale man enjoyed it also. It's not a car for everyone for sure. But, enjoyable neather the les. Most true sports cars have reliability issues. Some you can run hard and put away wet! While some your like " Dam I drove it hard . I'm going to have to take it to the shop tomorrow" and sixty thousand dollars on up! So, it seems to me! Thanks for letting me know! What I'm getting into. W.T.F. it's a sports car! But I bet money. If you crash or someone slam into your WRX/ STI. You'll be in pressed as you walk/drive away.

Mr.Impreza (not verified)    May 10, 2019 - 12:52PM

I had a 2002 wrx modded and it ran up to 186,000km without any issues. I sold it at that mileage. Now I own a 2018 STI stock and also zero issues. As others have mentioned. 90% of wrx and sti with issues tend to be modded and abused. Anyways I think Forves should go back to making who is the richest person list since they clearly don't know anything about cars.

Michael wu (not verified)    May 21, 2019 - 7:38AM

You said Subaru wrx sti is suck then can you find me a 4 doors sedan with standard all wheel, 6 speed manual for under 40k otd?

XV Clowntreck (not verified)    May 22, 2019 - 12:43PM

Subaru and its cult following, people need to take the blinders off and see that other manufactures build better cars. wear boxers for too long and get a rod knock.... these cars are clown cars.

Marcb (not verified)    May 23, 2019 - 9:12AM

Hey xv clowntrek, name another car that costs under 30 grand, gets 30mpg hwy, runs low to mid 12's in the quarter with just a little ethanol, a tune and exhaust, that will leave any pickup or suv behind in a blizzard? And only a tiny fraction of subarus ever made had "rod knock"... 100k BMW's, Audi and Mercedes have had broken connector rods and other MAJOR failures, and with low miles on them

Guillermo A. Sánchez (not verified)    July 13, 2019 - 10:14AM

WRX

I had one a 2015. It was fun, I liked it more than other car that I had before like for instance a GTI. It was more fun to drive, but in October 2018 I treated myself with the 2018 STI.

STI
First question:
How is it that a car that holds its value so well should be avoided?

Arguably, the feeling while driving an STI at any speed is so much more rewarding on the STI. The rumble, for starters, the feeling of the direction, the manual gear box. I kept it stock, with just the SPT exhaust system. I had M3s before, but there was no car that rewarded my driving like an STI. The happiness that produces is something what I would have wanted from a car when I was an adolescent car-enthusiast. It is a nimble car, with enough power, with a sound that reassures your brain that you're driving something special, unfortunately uncommon. It's so satisfying to open the hood and find that plastics do not dominate the picture and at the same time things are accesible.

I have a co-worker that felt annoyed by the rumble. It's not for everybody, of course, but if you liked cars, if you would dream of buying a 911 not dominated by the electronic intrusions, the current STI might be the car that you can afford.

If money weren't an issue, The car that I would love to drive the most just for the fun of driving would be the Porsche Speedster (from the one's that are offered new).

Subaru made a big mistake selling this amazing car with issues known to them between 2008-2017, but that being no longer an issue. The STI... I seen Focus RS, Civic Type-Rs, many competitors, but the STI would have been always my choice.

Love it like, no car I had!

But like girl at 21 might look in some way, then with time the STI might lose the rumble, like it happened in Japan, there are talks of even taking the manual transmission out of the car. It might become another numbed car. If that happens I would start checking the Veloster N, but not while the core characteristics are alive: Rumble, Manual transmission, great steering feeling, 3 LSD's (my GOD), a decent interior, the feeling that the car is a great machine that "you drive", not an electronic piece.

Subaru, thank you for the STI.

Robert Arutunian (not verified)    October 31, 2019 - 3:19PM

In reply to by Guillermo A. Sánchez (not verified)

Guillermo-you summed things up perfectly. I have nothing to add. Love my 2019 STI!

Catlady (not verified)    August 5, 2020 - 12:16PM

Over priced midlife crisis car that brings all kinds of trouble - not all of them problems with the car. Stay away from them and act your age.

Eriks Pavel (not verified)    January 10, 2022 - 8:55PM

We have a reliable tank storage and vessel Available at the port of Rotterdam,
port of Novorossiysk Russia and port of Houston USA. for lease urgently with strong focus on safety,
sustainability, reliability and customer service. Capacity: 3,926,249 cbm Tanks: 99 Tank size:
From 2,000 to 100,000 cbm Access: Barge, Pipeline, Vessel Draught: 21 meter Berths for barges:
15 Berths for vessels: 7 Products: Crude oil, aviation kerosene diesel oil, Petroleum products Services:
Blending, Heating, tank storage leasing & logistics, Dedicated systems, Additives. Terminal type: Hub, Import/Export/Distribution,
Industrial/Co Siting Division: BP Europe, Russia & United States. Ownership: 100.00% For TSA.
and all commercial inquiries, on leasing or sub-leasing, please contact Russia office via:+79167856894 on WhatsApp, Now let me know on
[email protected] that you sent or call us via those contact to secure your conversation!!