Skip to main content

My Toyota Tundra Suddenly Lost Power and I Need a New Engine, I’ve Been to the Dealer Countless Times, Now They Say My $60,000 Truck Is Only Worth $35K

Toyota Tundra truck owners are fuming because of the pickup's problems. Damien bought a 2022 Tundra, but the engine died. His truck has lost half its value, and now he's stuck with a dead truck. He's not the only one. Here is Damien's incredible story. 

The Toyota Tundra truck's reliability is dropping like a rock. 

Toyota Tundra truck owners are seething with frustration due to the pickup's persistent problems. Take Damien, for instance, who purchased a 2022 Tundra only to have the engine fail on him. His truck has depreciated by half its value, leaving him with a useless vehicle. And he's not alone. Here's Damien's harrowing experience.

If you've read my report on the Toyota Tundra engine issue, you're aware of the magnitude of the problem. The Japanese automaker must replace over 100,000 - 2022 and 2023 Tundra pickup and Lexus LX SUV engines with the V35A twin-turbo 3.4-liter V-6 power plant. This recall is not just a minor inconvenience but a significant disruption for Tundra owners. Read my full report here

Toyota's excellent reputation for building reliable vehicles is in serious decline. The recent Tundra recall to replace its 3.4-liter V-6 is the latest problem the automaker is facing. 

One of my readers, Damien Broomes, wrote to me about his 2022 Tundra truck. I'll share his comments along with other Tundra owners who are fuming because of the truck's reliability issues.  

Imagine driving your truck on a busy road on a Friday afternoon, going 55 miles an hour with your four-year-old daughter in the backseat. You purchased a Toyota Tundra because you wanted a safe vehicle for your young family. 

Suddenly, your truck engine loses power and dies in the middle of traffic. You have to make an emergency maneuver, pull the truck over, and deal with vehicles that are speeding past you. 

It's not a good situation. 

The worst thing is you have your daughter in the backseat who isn't happy with the situation. She picks up on your frustration and starts crying. Now you have a serious safety issue and a small child to deal with. 

You have to call your wife, tell her to calm down your little girl, and have her come and pick you up. You must also contact a tow truck company to get your truck out of the road. You are fuming mad.  

That's what happened to Damien. Here is his story. 

Damien says, "This is very concerning. I own a 2022 Toyota Tundra. On Friday, I suddenly lost engine power while driving on a main street at a pretty good speed." 

"My four-year-old daughter was sitting in the back seat. I immediately called the dealer, who strangely enough had called me just the week prior." 

"I was concerned for the safety of my kids and myself. Feeling hopeful, I thought I could trade the truck and get a new one."

Damien was shocked at what the dealer offered him for his truck.

"The dealership's offer was a mere $35,000 for my truck, which I had purchased two years ago for $60,000," he laments. 

If that wasn't bad enough, the Toyota dealer offered to sell him a used truck for the same price he paid for his truck two years ago. 

Damien says, "Then they offered me a pre-owned truck also at $60,000."

Damien has three options at this point because his truck is undrivable, and he needs a vehicle to drive. His wife has a car but needs it to drive to her job. 

It doesn't leave Damien with many options. He can:

  • 1. Sell the truck back to the Toyota dealer (at half the price he paid) 
  • 2. Trade the truck in and get a new one. 
  • 3. Wait on the new engine, which could take months.

Damien continues, "My question is this. Why would I be stuck with the price tag if the dealership sold me a lemon? This was no fault of mine; it was Toyota's mistake. I have been to the dealership countless times with this truck for various recalls and programming updates; I even had to replace the brake pad and disc in less than two years."

"As someone who drove the Tundra for 10 years, Toyota should do right by their customers and not ask them to foot the bill. That is certainly not customer service."

In my previous report on the Toyota Tundra recall, I detailed the lengthy process customers must endure to fix their trucks. Toyota has to replace the defective engines with new ones, a task that will take between 13 to 21 hours for each engine. 

With 100,000 engines being replaced, customers will be lined up waiting to get the work done. 

Tundra owners are left "holding the bag."

As Damien found out, and other Tundra owners are now concerned, engine failures affect the resale value of their trucks before they get the engine replacement. 

Here are some other comments from Toyota Tundra owners who have experienced similar issues. 

Chris R. - Owned a 23 Tundra TRD Pro Hybrid. The first motor failed at 19,500 miles. The dealer had the vehicle for 2.5 months and replaced the short block. I got the truck back 3 weeks, and 500 miles later, 2nd motor failed. I got rid of it last weekend. I would not accept anything short of a completely brand-new crate motor. You've been warned.

Mike H. - I have a 2022 Tundra SR5 Crewmax that experienced an engine issue back in early July. I usually drive in "sport mode," and as I went to pull out into traffic, and as you'll know, the throttle responds quickly, the rpm went to 5-6,000rpm, and instantly, my check engine light came on, and I lost power. 

Fortunately for me, no one was driving towards me, so I managed to steer my truck to the left onto a side road. I shut the truck off, waited for about 5 minutes, and then fired it back up. A warning came across the infotainment screen telling me to contact the dealer. 

Ever since that incident, I've noticed what I refer to as hiccups or a slight knock. I hope Toyota will send me the recall papers soon. I have been driving it to and from work because I have no other option. 

I also hope Toyota does what is right: Get your reputation back on track—crack down on quality control. Learn your lesson, and don't repeat it.

Walter Sysun - Great article! I own a 2022 Toyota Tundra Platinum, which is part of the engine recall.

Between the engine and fuel line recalls, I've been without using my truck for almost 8 months! Based on your article, It could be approaching a year without my truck. 

Toyota won't do a buyback, and they indicated that this recall doesn't fall under the Massachusetts Lemon Law. I do have a loaner, but not to the level of my truck. Toyota will not provide an exact date for the engine replacement! 

It's unacceptable to pay for a truck that I can't use and basically be kept in the dark by Toyota.

Conclusion.

Toyota Tundra owners like Damien are stuck with a truck that needs a new engine and has to wait months for the dealer to fit them in to get a replacement engine. Their trucks are worth half what they paid two years ago. 

It's not a good place for Toyota to put their loyal truck owners in. Is Toyota's stellar reputation dropping? Some say it's dropping like a rock. Check out this Toyota Tacoma story.

This expert says, "Toyota is Desperately Trying to Stop Their Brand Image From Taking a Straight Dumpster Dive, Now The Tacoma Transmissions Are Failing." Check out my report here

It's Your Turn

We want to hear from you. Do you have a 2022 or 2023 Toyota Tundra? Have you experienced any issues with the engine in your new truck? Click the red Add New Comment link below and let us know.

I am Denis Flierl, a Senior Torque News Reporter since 2012. My 30+ year tenure in the automotive industry, initially in a consulting role with every major car brand and later as a freelance journalist test-driving new vehicles, has equipped me with a wealth of knowledge. I specialize in reporting the latest automotive news and providing expert analysis on Subaru, which you'll find here, ensuring that you, as a reader, are always well-informed and up-to-date. Follow me on my X SubaruReport, All Subaru, WRXSTI, @DenisFlierl, Facebook, and Instagram.

Photo credit: Denis Flierl via Toyota dealer

Comments

Steven Spicer (not verified)    January 1, 2025 - 7:07PM

I had purchased a new 2022 Tundra and noticed my vehicle lost power while I attempted to back up my truck while attempting to park my boat in my driveway. I even put the truck in 4WD and the tires were spinning on blacktop and didn’t have the power to back up. I traded it for a different truck for that reason. I loved my truck, but had to trade.

Cory Dryden (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 1:35AM

In reply to by Steven Spicer (not verified)

You might want to review the Magnuson Moss warranty act, I believe it was dated 1974. It is a item that is in place to protect consumers who are in a week negotiating position, from dealers and manufacturers who are in a very strong negotiating position.
We took the manufacturer to arbitration in won. They were forced to replace my motor, which was under warranty.

Jonny Chi (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 1:50PM

In reply to by Steven Spicer (not verified)

If your wheels were spinning you had too much power for the traction. Nothing to do with the engines. Boats ramps are very slippery because of water obviously but also oil dripping from the boat motors. I doubt there was anything wrong with your truck.

Bob Haver (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 3:25PM

In reply to by Steven Spicer (not verified)

Sorry to hear things have gone so bad for toyota, I bought the original tundra in 2000 drove it for 23 years,had over 300k miles on it and only had to replace the starter once,besides tires and oil that was it.Best truck I ever had now I have a 2024 chev hd2500 been at the dealer 4 months and still can't fix it.

Mark Glass (not verified)    January 1, 2025 - 7:19PM

I also have a useless 2022 Tundra Crew Max SR5-TRD loaded with aftermarket improvements. After 5 recalls awaiting the big fix the new crate engine & harness package. TOYOTA OF BELLEVUE Has proven to be a Great Partner. Not so much the Dealer where it was purchased. My 60K plus truck is now worth about 38K once the new motor is complete. Have lost trust in the Brand not my Repair Dealer.

Lura Wight (not verified)    January 1, 2025 - 8:17PM

I have a 2023 Tundra Capstone bought new. I have not had any issues with it. It has 26,500 miles on it. This article is very concerning to me. I absolutely love the Capstone and plan to get another new one next time I buy.

Jim Marshall (not verified)    January 1, 2025 - 9:00PM

My 2023 Tundra Platinum engine failed at @ 14k miles. It took 3.5 months to replace!!! Drove a cheaper
rental ....I will NEVER buy anything from Toyota again. When my wife's Toyota Siena needs replacement - it sure won't be ANY Toyota!

Mike (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 7:45AM

In reply to by Jim Marshall (not verified)

I think he needs to find a better dealer.

As of today the repair time for the engine is 3 days 13hr book job. Toyota is releasing engines in batches and priority is given to failed engines. Ones the failures are covered they will repair the recalls. Several on the open recall list have reported dealers calling them and receiving engines. One would perceive that as plenty of engines out there.

Toyota will give you a rental during the repair. They will even give you a rental if you feel your recalled vehicle is unsafe to drive.

So while I feel bad for this guy, I don't think we are getting the whole story. Recalls happen all the time. Toyota is getting the parts out there and making good.

Gregory Borror (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 9:45AM

In reply to by Jim Marshall (not verified)

I recall (no pun intended) that I had with a young man who just pulled up in his shiny new 2021 Tundra. Asked him why he didn't get the new 2022? He said "What a hot mess". Boy oh boy was he right and I'm sure happy with his decision. I will keep my V8 2018 Tundra till one of us croaks.

Lance H (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 9:51AM

In reply to by Jim Marshall (not verified)

This is what happens when you buy a V6 engine that has not been tested. I'm not knocking Toyota owners, because I have been one and certainly I would presume that Toyota is still top notch in terms of reliability. Apparently they are not. I just got rid of my 2012 SR5 with 200,000 mi. Zero issues. I bought a 2018 Nissan Titan with a V8. Again, I have zero issues with my truck. It's time to stop jumping on the latest and greatest and start buying an older used, proven vehicle.

Rudy Caceres (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 10:42AM

In reply to by Jim Marshall (not verified)

"Wow, reading this article makes me appreciate my 2024 Toyota Tundra i-Force MAX even more! Seeing how quickly the 2022 model depreciated is eye-opening. Glad I opted for the latest model with improved reliability and features. My i-Force MAX has been a beast on the road, and I'm loving every mile. Kudos to Toyota for continuous innovation! Anyone considering a Tundra, I highly recommend exploring the latest models - worth every penny!

Matt (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 6:30AM

I'm curious as to why it doesn't fall under the Lemon law. Is it just because they say it doesn't? Seems like they sold 100k lemons and don't want to pay for it.

Joe (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 6:51AM

I had a 2013 Tundra with 168000 miles and never had an issue. I was in the market for a new truck. With all these issues and also at the suggestion of a service writer, I steered clear of another Toyota product and bought a new (different brand) truck. It’s going to take many years of watching Toyota get back on track successfully before I spend any money with them again.

Renato (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 8:09AM

Denis, I appreciate your story and I feel badly for the new truck owners. Unfortunately every Tundra model seems to have had some issues, but if resolved the results can be worthwhile.

I have a 2001 Tundra. It was my daily driver. At 75,000 miles I lost power and had it towed to the dealership. The transmission had totally failed. Toyota replaced it at no cost to me. When the truck reached 110,000 miles, I received a frame recall notice. At that point the truck was 15 years old and only used on weekends. I talked to the dealer and Toyota authorized the $12,000 repair (2016 dollars). The dealer had the truck for nearly four months. As they tried to take the truck apart, other elements were rusted and broke so they had to replace them as well. Toyota gave me whatever loaner I wanted and for fun, I tried all kinds of cars during the repair period. In the end, my truck was returned with a new frame, new shocks, all kinds of mounts etc. replaced. The Tundra is now at 175,000 miles and 23 years old. The clear coat is starting to peal, the leather seats are starting to dry out and crack, BUT the truck is still my weekend warrior. It starts up every time in all types of Midwest weather. At my usage rate, the truck may outlast me.

P.S. I also have a 2012 Sienna with 260,000 miles and a 2012 Highlander Limited with 240,000 miles that work perfectly with no unusual maintenance issues.

Mike (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 8:22AM

My 2022 Tundra has gone into limp mode twice while pulling my travel trailer. I was lucky to pull off a major interstate i35 without getting hit. Very scary helpless feeling!

Kelvin hart (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 8:33AM

I have a 2022 tundra limited hybrid I have 58000 miles on it have no complaints till recently it had a engine misfire stopped dead in the middle of the highway in on coming traffic was scary after 3to 5 seconds it fired back up. Took it to the dealer they said engine misfire no recall on your tundra wow. This is dangerous but nothing they can do

John Chiappetta (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 10:29AM

I don’t have a Tacoma I have a 2015 Highlander which I purchased used in 2021. Fortunately, when I purchased a car, I paid for an additional warranty to cover it up to 100,000 miles at 88,000 miles. my daughter was driving it and it started acting up and it turned out. It needed a new transmission Well that may not sign much in comparison to the Tacoma situation. I was absolutely stunned that a Toyota would require such a substantial repair with that type of mileage. It was a terrible experience as it took the dealership close to five months to finally address. All the issues were related to the replacement of the transmission, including persistent issues with the engine warning light coming on.

Kingprince (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 10:43AM

Honestly, I’m beyond frustrated with Toyota at this point. My 2022 Tundra Limited has been sitting at the dealership for almost 7 months waiting for an engine replacement, and I still have no idea when it’ll be fixed. This was my first brand-new truck, and I’m paying for a premium vehicle that I can’t even drive.

I want to be clear—this isn’t about the dealership. They’ve been great and provided me with a loaner, but it’s nowhere near what I should be driving. My issue is with Toyota and how poorly this whole situation has been handled.

After all this time, I feel like my only options are either a full refund or a brand-new truck. I’m not sure I’ll ever buy another Toyota after this experience. A company with such a strong reputation should be doing way better by its customers.

Paul (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 11:02AM

Our 2022 SR5 died in a similar fashion while pulling our trailer at highway speeds. Very scary but thankfully it wasn't a super busy highway. We had to get the truck towed which took 6 hours before they could get it. Plus somehow unhook our trailer and arrange for it to be taken to its parking spot. Truck was eventually towed to closest dealer which is about an hour away. They offered a discounted rental vehicle so it still cost us 500$ for a months rental and we had no truck for 4 months. I only took the rental for about 6 weeks as it was dumb to have to keep paying for something that was not our fault. Toyota Canada refused to fully pay for offer us a vehicle during this time.

Dean Lewis (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 11:13AM

That's these modern manufacturers for ya. Sell the truck and get something from the 1980s and older that's actually reliable. Anything modern ESPECIALLY TOYOTA is junk. I sold all my new stuff and relaxed it with old military surplus equipment and I never looked back.

Brian D Beans (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 11:20AM

The fact that Toyota provides a loaner vehicle at no cost to the customer should be mentioned.

Robert Schmitt (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 11:24AM

2009 toyota venza use 2 to 4 qt of oil in 5k miles. Oil rings are too small. They will not repair with recall kit even it I pay for it. This is my last toyota I will buy.

Bill (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 12:42PM

Oh... you raced out and paid $60k for a vehicle that underwent an enormous update to incorporate a smaller displacement turbo engine and hybridization? When you could have easily just bought a previous gen Tundra with a rock-solid, reliable engine and basically all the same features as the new one? What was your rationale here? I'm assuming it's because you wanted to impress the people in your neighborhood with your new shiny truck. Or maybe you rationalized your purchase with goofy features like lane departure or Apple CarPlay. Welp, now it's worth less than than the previous gen Tundra and you've got a dead motor to boot. I just find it hard to garner any sympathy for all these people who continue to fuel the ridiculous increase in new vehicle prices. It seems as if there's no limit to how high manufacturers will go, and you all line up like good little consumers to pay. As long as that monthly payment is as low as possible, that's all you care about. And yes, I'm sure everyone reading this is "the exception" and makes a million dollars a year. Good for you, but you still lost half the value of your precious status symbol.

Brent Jatko (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 1:54PM

$60000 for a truck is absurd territory.

That being said, Toyota should foot the bill for repairs, provided maintenance was done properly, of course.

John Branch (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 2:42PM

I have a 2022 Tundra that I ordered and waited 3 months for. It had multiple recalls which were causing it to be at the dealers while waited or got a loaner. Because of the recall I drive the truck very little due to thr safety warning from Toyota about the engine recall. Have just passed 6,000. Miles. Got a second notice to contact my dealer to get new engine. Dealer notified they can only order 1 engine at a time and it will take 3 or more months and put me on there list. This is my last Toyota.

Don (not verified)    January 2, 2025 - 3:50PM

I purchased a new 2022 from the factory. I have had recall after recall.While driving at 70mph I to loat power, lights all over the dash,contact dealer. I shut it down for 5 minutes and it returned to some what normal.Juat. got info on new motor and should be early February. Also dont guess this is new for the drivers side seat panel to break.

Philip Ashley (not verified)    January 3, 2025 - 5:43AM

This is old news, why, at this time, are you stirring the pot. Toyota have already said, they are replacing over 100,000 engines, free of charge. I believe changing engines has already begun.

Vince B (not verified)    January 3, 2025 - 12:49PM

Got my 2023 SR5 Tundra in March of 2023 and have had no issues - 13k miles. Ill be getting a new motor with the recall.

Gary-Bishara Lucas (not verified)    January 3, 2025 - 1:18PM

Had my engine replaced at 5k on a 2023 GR86. My car was in the shop for three weeks.I was given a loaner at no charge even an uber twice. The mechanic was experience with putting new engine back in car they could get engine in crate because Subaru only has parts. The engine has had no problems great at a MA dealership. No cost me. For those dedicated tooth's blog there is a pending class action suit for GR86 owners.